An original Thinka practice paper modelled on the structure and difficulty of the Nov 2024 (V1) Cambridge International A Level Geography (0460) paper. Not affiliated with or reproduced from Cambridge.
Paper 11 Geographical Themes
Answer three questions in total, one from each section (Theme 1: Population and Settlement, Theme 2: The Natural Environment, Theme 3: Economic Development).
33 Question · 96 marks
Question 1 · Short Answer
1.5 marks
Identify one pull factor that attracts migrants from rural areas to major urban areas in LEDCs, and briefly explain how this factor leads to urban growth.
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
A common pull factor is the prospect of employment. When rural populations migrate to cities for work, it directly increases the urban population. Additionally, these migrants are typically young adults of reproductive age, which leads to higher birth rates and rapid natural increase in urban centers.
Marking scheme
1 mark for identifying a valid pull factor (e.g., employment, better education, healthcare, higher wages). 0.5 marks for explaining how it drives urban growth (e.g., direct population transfer or subsequent natural increase).
Question 2 · Short Answer
1.5 marks
Explain how hydraulic action contributes to the erosion of a river channel.
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
Hydraulic action relies on the physical force of water pushing air into cracks in the river banks or bed. As the compressed air expands violently when the water recedes, it weakens and breaks apart the rock structure.
Marking scheme
1 mark for detailing the compression of air in cracks by the force of water. 0.5 marks for describing the explosive expansion/release of pressure that shatters the rock.
Question 3 · Short Answer
1.5 marks
Explain why the Human Development Index (HDI) is a more reliable measure of a country's level of development than Gross National Income (GNI) per capita alone.
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
GNI per capita is purely economic and can be skewed by extremely wealthy elites, masking poverty. HDI combines GNI per capita with adult literacy, school enrollment, and life expectancy at birth, offering a more balanced view of both standard of living and social well-being.
Marking scheme
1 mark for explaining that HDI is a composite indicator containing both social (health/education) and economic measures. 0.5 marks for contrasting with GNI per capita (e.g., explaining how GNI per capita ignores social dimensions or masks wealth inequalities).
Question 4 · Short Answer
1.5 marks
Describe the typical shape of a population pyramid for a country with a high birth rate and a high death rate (such as one in Stage 1 or 2 of the Demographic Transition Model).
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
A population pyramid for a country in Stage 1 or early Stage 2 has a wide base because birth rates are high, representing a large youth population. It narrows rapidly towards the top (concave slope) because high infant mortality and death rates mean very few people survive into old age.
Marking scheme
1 mark for describing the wide base (indicative of high birth rates). 0.5 marks for describing the rapidly narrowing/tapering top or concave sides (indicative of high death rates/low life expectancy).
Question 5 · Short Answer
1.5 marks
Explain the process of longshore drift along a coastline.
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
Longshore drift occurs when waves approach the beach at an angle determined by the prevailing wind. The swash pushes sediment up the beach at this oblique angle, while gravity pulls the backwash straight down the slope at a 90-degree angle, moving sediment along the coastline in a zig-zag pattern.
Marking scheme
1 mark for describing the swash moving sediment up the beach at an oblique angle dictated by prevailing winds. 0.5 marks for describing gravity pulling the backwash straight back down, resulting in a cumulative zig-zag transport.
Question 6 · Short Answer
1.5 marks
State one negative environmental impact of rapid tourism development on a coastal area, and suggest a sustainable strategy to manage it.
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
Rapid development of coastal hotels and recreational facilities leads to the degradation of local ecosystems such as coral reefs (through sewage disposal or anchor damage) or sand dunes (through foot trampling). A sustainable strategy is implementing zoning laws, creating protected reserves, or setting daily visitor quotas to reduce ecological footprints.
Marking scheme
1 mark for identifying a valid environmental impact (e.g., habitat loss, water pollution, dune erosion). 0.5 marks for suggesting an appropriate, sustainable management strategy (e.g., zoning, visitor limits, eco-tourism guidelines, protective structures).
Question 7 · Short Answer
1.5 marks
Explain the relationship between the threshold population of a service and its range.
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
Threshold population is the minimum market size needed to make a service economically viable. Range is the maximum distance a customer will travel to use it. High-order services (like specialist hospitals or luxury car dealerships) have a high threshold and thus need a very large geographical range to ensure they capture enough customers.
Marking scheme
1 mark for defining or explaining both terms correctly (threshold population as minimum people needed, range as maximum distance traveled). 0.5 marks for explaining the positive relationship (high threshold requires a larger range to capture the necessary population).
Question 8 · Short Answer
1.5 marks
Describe how constructive (divergent) plate boundaries lead to volcanic activity.
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
At constructive boundaries, plates diverge (move apart). This movement thins the crust and reduces pressure on the underlying mantle, causing magma to rise. This rising magma erupts onto the surface, often producing gentle, effusive volcanic eruptions that build flat, broad shield volcanoes over time.
Marking scheme
1 mark for describing the physical parting of plates and the resulting gap/fracture. 0.5 marks for explaining that magma rises to fill this gap, cooling to create new land/volcanoes.
Question 9 · short_answer
1.5 marks
Identify three physical or land use characteristics typically associated with the Central Business District (CBD) of a major urban settlement.
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
In urban settlements, the Central Business District (CBD) is characterized by intense competition for land, leading to high land values. To maximize space, buildings are built tall (high-rise), and land is predominantly used for commercial, retail, and office spaces rather than residential or industrial purposes.
Marking scheme
Award 0.5 marks for each of three distinct characteristics identified. Acceptable answers include: high density of high-rise buildings, high land values, concentration of commercial/retail/offices, high pedestrian density, focus of public transport routes, lack of residential or industrial land use.
Question 10 · short_answer
1.5 marks
State three distinct reasons why rapid urbanisation in LEDCs frequently leads to the expansion of informal settlements.
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
Rapid urbanisation creates a massive influx of migrants. Municipal governments lack the funds and planning capacity to build affordable housing quickly enough, and because many migrants have low incomes or work in the informal sector, they cannot afford formal housing, forcing them to build informal shelters on marginal land.
Marking scheme
Award 0.5 marks for each of three distinct reasons stated. Acceptable answers: rural-to-urban migration rate exceeds house building capacity, lack of affordable housing options, high level of poverty/unemployment among migrants, lack of government planning or land enforcement.
Question 11 · short_answer
1.5 marks
Describe three environmental conditions required for the healthy growth and development of coral reefs.
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
Coral reefs are highly sensitive ecosystems requiring warm sea temperatures (optimally between \(20^{\circ}\text{C}\) and \(30^{\circ}\text{C}\)), shallow depths so that symbiotic zooxanthellae algae can perform photosynthesis, and clear, unpolluted saltwater to prevent the polyps from being smothered by sediment.
Marking scheme
Award 0.5 marks for each of three correct environmental conditions described: Warm water temperature (accept range \(20\text{--}30^{\circ}\text{C}\)), shallow water (accept depths less than \(60\text{ m}\)), clear/sediment-free water, high salinity/saltwater, well-oxygenated water.
Question 12 · short_answer
1.5 marks
Identify three physical adaptations of vegetation in hot desert climates that enable survival under severe drought conditions.
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
Hot desert plants (xerophytes) adapt physically to extreme aridity. They store water in fleshy tissue (succulence), develop extremely long taproots or wide-reaching shallow roots to capture water, and reduce surface area with waxy coatings or spines instead of broad leaves to minimize transpiration.
Marking scheme
Award 0.5 marks for each of three distinct adaptations identified: succulent/fleshy stems or leaves, long taproots or extensive shallow root networks, waxy cuticles, spines or needle-like leaves (to reduce transpiration), seeds that can remain dormant for long periods.
Question 13 · short_answer
1.5 marks
Distinguish between the river processes of hydraulic action, attrition, and solution by briefly describing each process.
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
These are three distinct types of river processes. Hydraulic action is the sheer force of water trapping and compressing air inside cracks of the bed and banks, eventually shattering the rock. Attrition occurs when pebbles and stones carried by the river collide with each other, becoming smaller and rounder. Solution is the chemical breakdown of soluble rocks, such as limestone, by weak acids in the river water.
Marking scheme
Award 0.5 marks for each correct description: Hydraulic action (force of water trapping/compressing air in cracks), Attrition (rocks/bedload colliding and wearing down/becoming smaller/rounder), Solution (chemical dissolving/dissolution of minerals/rocks by the water).
Question 14 · short_answer
1.5 marks
State three different social indicators used to measure the level of development of a country.
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
Social indicators of development measure non-monetary aspects of quality of life and human well-being. Common indicators include life expectancy (reflecting healthcare quality), adult literacy rate (reflecting education access), and infant mortality rate (reflecting basic pediatric health, nutrition, and sanitation).
Marking scheme
Award 0.5 marks for each of three valid social indicators stated. Acceptable answers include: Life expectancy, adult literacy rate, infant mortality rate, maternal mortality rate, primary school enrollment rate, number of doctors per 1000 people, access to safe drinking water/sanitation.
Question 15 · short_answer
1.5 marks
State three negative environmental impacts associated with rapid and unplanned coastal tourism development.
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
Unplanned coastal tourism often leads to immediate environmental degradation. Construction of hotels can destroy protective sand dunes and mangrove forests. Lack of infrastructure can lead to the discharge of raw sewage, polluting marine habitats. Increased tourist activity and boat anchors can physically damage coral reefs.
Marking scheme
Award 0.5 marks for each of three distinct negative environmental impacts stated. Acceptable answers: habitat destruction (mangroves, dunes), water/sewage pollution, damage to coral reefs (from anchors/divers), increased litter/solid waste, air/noise pollution from tourist vehicles.
Question 16 · short_answer
1.5 marks
Explain three reasons why many low-income countries (LEDCs) continue to experience high birth rates.
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
High birth rates in LEDCs are driven by several socio-economic factors. Families often rely on children as an economic asset to work on subsistence farms and support parents in old age due to a lack of state pensions. High infant mortality rates motivate larger families to ensure some survive, and access to contraceptive services is often severely limited.
Marking scheme
Award 0.5 marks for each of three valid reasons explained: economic need for children (e.g., agricultural labor, old-age support), high infant mortality rate (replacement births), lack of family planning/contraceptives, cultural or religious traditions favoring large families, young age of marriage/high fertility window.
Question 17 · short_answer
1.5 marks
Explain why informal settlements (squatter settlements) in LEDC cities are frequently built on steep hillsides, and state one physical hazard that residents on these slopes face during heavy rainfall.
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
First, informal settlements are built on steep hillsides because this land is marginal, unsafe, or undesirable for formal commercial or residential development, leaving it unoccupied and easy for low-income migrants to claim. Second, during periods of heavy rainfall, these steep, often deforested slopes become highly unstable, leading to a high risk of landslides or mudslides that can sweep away shelters.
Marking scheme
Award 1 mark for explaining that the land is marginal, cheap, unoccupied, or unwanted by formal developers. Award 0.5 marks for identifying landslides, mudslides, or soil erosion as the physical hazard.
Question 18 · short_answer
1.5 marks
Describe how longshore drift transports sediment along a coastline, and identify the physical change in the coastline's shape that is required for a spit to begin to form.
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
Sediment is transported along the coast by longshore drift, where waves carry material up the beach at an angle as swash, and gravity pulls it straight back down as backwash, creating a zig-zag movement. For a spit to form, there must be a sudden change in the coastline's direction, such as a river estuary or a bay, causing wave energy to drop and deposit the carried sediment.
Marking scheme
Award 1 mark for describing the zig-zag movement of sediment (swash moving up at an angle and backwash moving straight down). Award 0.5 marks for stating that the coastline must suddenly change direction, turn, or meet an estuary mouth.
Question 19 · Structured Explanation
4 marks
Explain why birth rates remain high in many Less Economically Developed Countries (LEDCs).
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
In many LEDCs, primary economic activities like subsistence farming require a large labor force, making children economic assets rather than liabilities. Furthermore, without state-funded pension systems, parents rely on their children for care in old age. High infant mortality rates create an insurance effect where families have additional children to guarantee survival to adulthood. Social and cultural factors, such as early marriage and religious beliefs that discourage contraception, along with limited female education, also keep birth rates high.
Marking scheme
Award 1 mark for each explained reason up to 4 marks. [1 mark] for explaining high infant mortality (e.g., parents have more children to ensure some survive). [1 mark] for explaining economic utility (e.g., children work on family farms to generate income). [1 mark] for explaining social or religious factors (e.g., opposition to artificial contraception due to religious beliefs). [1 mark] for explaining lack of family planning (e.g., limited access to clinic services and sex education).
Question 20 · Structured Explanation
4 marks
Explain how rapid urbanisation can lead to environmental challenges in LEDC cities.
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
As cities grow rapidly, the local infrastructure cannot keep pace. Lack of sewage treatment results in raw waste being discharged directly into local rivers, contaminating water sources. High volumes of vehicles, often older and poorly maintained, cause severe traffic congestion and release high levels of greenhouse gases and particulate matter. Informal housing developments (slums) expand onto fragile hillsides and wetlands, destroying local ecosystems and leading to deforestation and soil erosion. Additionally, the lack of official waste management leads to widespread open dumping of trash.
Marking scheme
Award up to 4 marks for well-explained environmental challenges. [1 mark] for explaining water pollution (e.g., lack of sewerage leading to contamination of rivers). [1 mark] for explaining air pollution (e.g., increased emissions from old vehicles in heavy traffic). [1 mark] for explaining habitat loss (e.g., clearing of forests or wetlands to build informal housing). [1 mark] for explaining solid waste accumulation (e.g., open burning of garbage due to absence of municipal collection services).
Question 21 · Structured Explanation
4 marks
Explain why people continue to live in areas close to active volcanoes.
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
Despite the risks, volcanic regions offer significant advantages. For farmers, volcanic ash contains high concentrations of minerals like potassium and phosphorus, producing highly fertile soils that allow multiple crop harvests per year. Geothermal heat can be converted into cheap, renewable energy for local communities. The unique geological features also create a thriving tourism industry, offering diverse job opportunities. Finally, mineral extraction (e.g., sulfur mining) provides a steady source of income for local workers who have few other employment options.
Marking scheme
Award 1 mark for each explained reason up to 4 marks. [1 mark] for explaining agricultural benefits (e.g., mineral-rich fertile soil leads to high crop yields). [1 mark] for explaining geothermal energy (e.g., utilizing underground heat to produce cheap, green electricity). [1 mark] for explaining tourism opportunities (e.g., scenic views or geysers attract tourists, creating jobs in hospitality). [1 mark] for explaining resource extraction (e.g., mining valuable volcanic minerals like sulfur provides local income).
Question 22 · Structured Explanation
4 marks
Explain how lateral erosion and deposition form a meander in a river's middle course.
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
In the middle course, the river channel bends, causing water to be flung to the outer bank by centrifugal force. Here, the water is deep, friction is low, and velocity is high. This high energy results in rapid lateral erosion (by abrasion and hydraulic action), creating a steep river cliff. Conversely, on the inner bend, the water is shallow, friction is high, and velocity is low. Lacking the energy to carry its load, the river deposits sediment here, creating a slip-off slope. These concurrent processes cause the meander to migrate and become more exaggerated.
Marking scheme
Award up to 4 marks for explaining the processes on both outer and inner bends. [1 mark] for explaining high velocity on the outer bend due to low friction. [1 mark] for explaining lateral erosion (hydraulic action or abrasion) forming a river cliff on the outer bend. [1 mark] for explaining low velocity on the inner bend due to high friction. [1 mark] for explaining deposition forming a slip-off slope on the inner bend.
Question 23 · Structured Explanation
4 marks
Explain how longshore drift leads to the formation of a coastal spit.
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
Longshore drift is the primary driver of spit formation. Prevailing winds cause waves to approach the beach at an oblique angle. The swash carries sand and shingle up the beach at this angle. The backwash retreats at a right angle (90 degrees) to the shoreline, pulled by gravity. This creates a zig-zag movement of sediment along the coast. When the coastline turns sharply (e.g., at an estuary or bay), the longshore drift continues in the original direction, depositing sediment in the sheltered, lower-energy waters. Continuous deposition builds up a ridge of sand and shingle that extends out into the sea, forming a spit.
Marking scheme
Award up to 4 marks. [1 mark] for explaining how swash carries sediment up the beach at an angle determined by the prevailing wind. [1 mark] for explaining how backwash moves sediment straight down the beach under gravity. [1 mark] for defining longshore drift as this zig-zag movement of material along the coast. [1 mark] for explaining how a change in coastline shape causes sediment to be deposited in calmer waters, eventually building up above sea level.
Question 24 · Structured Explanation
4 marks
Explain how physical factors can cause food shortages in a region.
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
Food production is highly vulnerable to natural conditions. A lack of rainfall (drought) prevents crops from photosynthesizing and growing, while drying up water sources for livestock. Conversely, excessive rainfall causes flooding, which physically destroys crops, waterlogs the soil, and washes away fertile nutrients from the topsoil. Temperature anomalies, such as severe heatwaves, accelerate soil moisture evaporation and stress crops, while unexpected frosts kill young plants. Furthermore, natural biological events like pest infestations (e.g., desert locusts) or plant fungal diseases can rapidly decimate crops over vast areas, causing critical shortages.
Marking scheme
Award 1 mark for each physical factor and its direct mechanism of reducing food supply, up to 4 marks. [1 mark] for explaining how drought leads to crop failure or death of livestock. [1 mark] for explaining how flooding drowns crops or erodes fertile topsoil. [1 mark] for explaining how extreme temperatures (frosts or heatwaves) damage plant growth or reduce yields. [1 mark] for explaining how pests or diseases destroy harvests.
Question 25 · Structured Explanation
4 marks
Explain how the growth of tourism can have negative impacts on the natural environment of an area.
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
The rapid development of tourist facilities often occurs at the expense of the natural environment. Constructing hotels, airports, and recreational facilities requires clearing vegetation, which fragments habitats and drives away native species. Tourism increases the production of waste; in many developing destinations, poor sewage management leads to untreated effluent leaking into coastal waters, killing coral reefs. Tourists also consume disproportionate amounts of fresh water, lowering local aquifers and leaving less water for natural ecosystems. Finally, recreational activities like motorboating or off-road driving cause noise pollution and physically damage fragile habitats.
Marking scheme
Award 1 mark for each explained negative environmental impact, up to 4 marks. [1 mark] for explaining habitat destruction due to hotel or infrastructure construction. [1 mark] for explaining water pollution from untreated sewage or littering by tourists. [1 mark] for explaining water scarcity caused by high demand from resorts (e.g., pools, golf courses). [1 mark] for explaining wildlife disturbance or air and noise pollution from increased transport and tourist activities.
Question 26 · Structured Explanation
4 marks
Explain how the Human Development Index (HDI) measures a country's level of development.
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
To provide a broader measure of development than GDP alone, the United Nations uses the HDI, which compiles data across three vital sectors. First, the health dimension is represented by life expectancy at birth, indicating the quality of healthcare and nutrition. Second, the education dimension uses two metrics: the average number of school years completed by adults aged 25 and over, and the estimated years of schooling a child starting school can expect to receive. Third, the standard of living is measured using GNI per capita at purchasing power parity (PPP), reflecting actual consumer purchasing power. These indicators are indexed together to give a score from 0 (lowest development) to 1 (highest development).
Marking scheme
Award up to 4 marks. [1 mark] for stating that HDI is a composite index combining multiple measures of social and economic development. [1 mark] for explaining that health is measured by life expectancy at birth. [1 mark] for explaining that education is measured using mean or expected years of schooling. [1 mark] for explaining that standard of living is measured by GNI per capita adjusted for purchasing power parity (PPP).
Question 27 · Structured Explanation
4 marks
Explain how rapid urbanisation can lead to environmental problems in and around cities in LEDCs.
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
Rapid urbanisation in LEDCs often occurs faster than city infrastructure can be constructed, leading to severe environmental degradation:
1. Water Pollution: Many rapid-growth areas, particularly informal squatter settlements, lack basic sanitation. As a result, raw sewage and household waste are dumped directly into local rivers and water bodies, destroying aquatic ecosystems. 2. Air Pollution: The rapid increase in population leads to more vehicles (often older, poorly maintained ones) on congested roads. This, combined with industrial growth and unregulated factory emissions, results in heavy smog and toxic air quality. 3. Land Pollution: Local governments cannot cope with the sheer volume of municipal waste generated, leading to open landfills, uncontrolled dumping of rubbish on streets, and the leaching of hazardous chemicals into the soil. 4. Deforestation and Habitat Loss: As cities sprawl outward, natural forests and green spaces are cleared to make room for squatter settlements, roads, and factories, leading to a loss of biodiversity.
Marking scheme
Award 1 mark for each explained environmental problem up to a maximum of 4 marks: - Water pollution due to lack of sanitation/untreated sewage discharge (1 mark) - Air pollution/smog due to vehicle exhaust emissions/industrial activities (1 mark) - Land pollution/accumulation of garbage due to inadequate municipal waste collection systems (1 mark) - Loss of biodiversity/deforestation/destruction of ecosystems on the urban fringe to clear land for housing/infrastructure (1 mark)
Note: - Do not credit social or economic impacts (e.g. unemployment, poverty, crime, lack of housing) unless explicitly linked to an environmental effect. - Do not double-count similar points (e.g. water pollution from sewage and water pollution from factories count as one general point for water pollution unless distinct environmental mechanisms are explained).
Question 28 · Structured Explanation
4 marks
Explain how a river transports its load using the processes of traction, saltation, suspension, and solution.
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
Rivers transport material downstream through four distinct processes determined by the size and weight of the load:
1. Traction: This process moves the largest and heaviest rocks and boulders. These materials are too heavy to be lifted by the river flow, so they are rolled or pushed along the river bed by the sheer force of the water. 2. Saltation: This process transports medium-sized pebbles and gravel. The force of the water temporarily lifts these particles off the river bed, causing them to bounce or hop along the bottom in a leapfrog motion. 3. Suspension: This process carries very fine, light particles such as silt and clay. These particles are held up and carried within the body of the flowing water, never touching the river bed until the velocity drops. 4. Solution: This process transports soluble minerals (such as calcium carbonate from limestone). These minerals dissolve chemically in the water and are carried invisibly in solution.
Marking scheme
Award 1 mark for each correctly explained transportation process (maximum of 4 marks): - Traction: Large stones/boulders (1 mark) rolled or pushed along the river bed (1 mark). - Saltation: Medium pebbles/gravel (1 mark) bounced/hopped along the river bed (1 mark). - Suspension: Fine particles/silt/clay (1 mark) carried/suspended within the flow of water (1 mark). - Solution: Soluble minerals/chemicals (1 mark) dissolved in the water and carried invisibly (1 mark).
Note: - To gain the mark, the candidate must describe the mechanism of movement, not just name the process.
Question 29 · Structured Explanation
4 marks
Explain how vegetation in the tropical rainforest has adapted to survive in the hot, wet climate.
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
Vegetation in tropical rainforests has evolved several highly specialized physical adaptations to thrive in the constant high temperatures and heavy rainfall:
1. Drip-tips: Leaves have pointed tips and a waxy surface which allows heavy rainfall to run off quickly. This prevents the leaves from breaking under the weight of the water and stops mold, algae, and fungi from growing on them in the humid conditions. 2. Buttress Roots: Because nutrients are concentrated in the very top layer of the soil and the soil is wet and unstable, trees do not have deep taproots. Instead, they have massive, shallow buttress roots that spread out above ground to support the weight of trees growing up to 40-50 meters tall. 3. Lianas: These are woody vines that take root in the soil but use the trunks of larger trees to climb up to the canopy layer, allowing them to reach sunlight without having to grow a thick, energy-expensive trunk of their own. 4. Thin Bark: Unlike trees in temperate climates, rainforest trees do not need thick bark to protect against freezing temperatures. The thin, smooth bark allows water to flow easily down the trunk and prevents other parasitic plants from taking root on the surface.
Marking scheme
Award 1 mark for each identified adaptation linked to a valid explanation of how it helps survival (maximum 4 marks): - Drip-tips / waxy leaves (1 mark) to shed heavy rain rapidly / prevent rotting or damage (1 mark). - Buttress roots (1 mark) to stabilize/support tall trees in shallow/wet soils (1 mark). - Lianas / epiphytes (1 mark) to climb/grow high up to reach sunlight in the canopy (1 mark). - Broad leaves (1 mark) to maximize sunlight absorption in the dark forest floor/undercanopy (1 mark). - Thin/smooth bark (1 mark) as protection against cold/frost is unnecessary / allows transpiration/water runoff (1 mark).
Note: - Simply listing adaptations (e.g., 'buttress roots, drip-tips, lianas') without explanation can score a maximum of 2 marks.
Question 30 · Structured Explanation
4 marks
Explain how the development of tourism can have negative economic impacts on local communities.
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
While tourism can bring wealth, its rapid development often introduces several negative economic challenges for local populations:
1. Economic Leakage: A large percentage of the money spent by tourists does not stay in the local economy. Instead, it leaks back to foreign-owned airlines, multinational hotel chains, and international tour operators who organize the holidays. 2. Seasonal Unemployment: Tourism is often a highly seasonal industry. Local workers (e.g., hotel staff, lifeguards, tour guides) may only find employment for a few months of the year, leading to financial instability and unemployment during the off-season. 3. Price Inflation: The influx of wealthier tourists drives up local prices. The cost of food, transport, land, and housing often rises significantly, making basic necessities and real estate unaffordable for local residents. 4. Over-dependency: If a local economy relies too heavily on tourism, it becomes highly vulnerable. External events such as natural disasters, political instability, epidemics, or economic recessions in source countries can cause tourism to collapse, leaving the local community without alternative livelihoods.
Marking scheme
Award 1 mark for each explained negative economic impact (maximum of 4 marks): - Economic leakage: profits go out of the country to foreign-owned hotel chains/airlines (1 mark). - Seasonal unemployment: jobs are temporary/only in peak season, leaving workers without income in the off-season (1 mark). - Inflation/increased cost of living: tourists drive up the cost of goods/services/housing, making them unaffordable for locals (1 mark). - Over-dependency/vulnerability: economic collapse if tourism numbers drop due to pandemics/natural disasters/political unrest (1 mark). - Low-paid/low-skill jobs: locals are often employed only in low-paying service roles (e.g., cleaning, waiting tables) while high-paid management jobs go to foreigners (1 mark). - Opportunity cost: government funds are diverted to build tourist infrastructure (airports, beach lounges) instead of public services like schools or hospitals (1 mark).
Note: - Do not accept environmental impacts (e.g., coral damage, litter) or social impacts (e.g., cultural dilution, crime) unless they are explicitly and directly linked to an economic cost.
Question 31 · case_study
7 marks
For a named urban area you have studied, describe the problems caused by rapid urban growth (urbanisation) and explain how these problems are being managed.
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
Example Case Study: Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. Problems caused by rapid urbanisation: Over 20% of the population live in informal settlements (favelas) such as Rocinha, where houses are built on steep, unstable slopes prone to landslides. Lack of basic infrastructure leads to untreated sewage entering water bodies like Guanabara Bay, and waterborne diseases like cholera are common. High unemployment rates in the formal sector have forced many into the informal sector or organized crime, leading to high rates of drug-related violence in the favelas. Traffic congestion is severe, leading to high levels of air pollution in the narrow valley streets. Management of these problems: The Favela-Bairro Project (a site-and-service scheme) has upgraded conditions in several favelas by replacing temporary wooden shelters with brick-and-mortar homes, installing proper drainage systems, and laying paved roads to allow emergency vehicle access. To tackle isolation and transport issues, a cable car system was constructed in the Complexo do Alemão favela group, allowing residents to easily commute to the main railway network. Pacifying Police Units (UPPs) have been deployed to reclaim control of favelas from drug gangs and restore safety, allowing public services like trash collection to function. To combat water pollution, new sewage treatment works have been built near Barra da Tijuca to reduce the amount of raw waste entering the bay.
Marking scheme
Level 1 (1 to 3 marks): Simple statements describing problems of urbanisation and/or simple statements of management. (e.g., Houses are overcrowded. There is a lot of crime. The government builds better houses. They built a cable car.) Level 2 (4 to 6 marks): Developed statements describing the problems of urbanisation in a named urban area and/or explaining how specific management strategies address them. (e.g., In favelas like Rocinha, homes are built on steep, unstable hillsides, which makes them highly vulnerable to collapse during heavy tropical rainstorms. To address this, the Favela-Bairro scheme has built concrete retaining walls on slopes to prevent landslides and replaced wooden shacks with stable brick homes. Note: Max 5 marks if no named urban area is given or if the example is inappropriate.) Level 3 (7 marks): Level 2 answers which include specific, detailed information about the chosen urban area, including place-specific names, statistics, and/or named schemes. (e.g., Must include specific details such as Rocinha, Complexo do Alemão, Favela-Bairro Project, UPPs, or quantitative statistics like 20% of population in favelas, specific dates/costs of schemes.)
Question 32 · case_study
7 marks
For a named coastal area you have studied, explain how the coast is managed to protect it from erosion and/or flooding.
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
Example Case Study: The Holderness Coast, Yorkshire, UK. The Holderness Coast is eroding rapidly at an average rate of 2 metres per year due to weak boulder clay cliffs and strong destructive waves from the North Sea. Management strategies and explanations: At Mappleton, a £2 million scheme was implemented in 1991 to protect the village and the vital B1242 coastal road. Two massive rock groynes were built using Scandinavian granite. These groynes trap sediment transported by longshore drift, creating a wide sandy beach. This wide beach acts as a natural buffer, absorbing wave energy and preventing waves from directly attacking the base of the boulder clay cliffs. Also at Mappleton, a rock revetment (rip-rap) consisting of large boulders was placed along the base of the cliff. This structure breaks up incoming wave energy and reduces the power of hydraulic action and abrasion, preventing cliff undercutting. At Withernsea, a vertical concrete sea wall was replaced by a recurved sea wall to deflect the energy of destructive waves back out to sea, and rock armour was placed at its base to prevent scouring. However, these strategies have had knock-on effects. By trapping sediment at Mappleton, the beach further downdrift at Great Cowden was starved of sand. This has accelerated erosion rates at Great Cowden, leading to the loss of farmland and caravan parks.
Marking scheme
Level 1 (1 to 3 marks): Simple statements identifying coastal management methods and/or reasons for protection. (e.g., They put rock walls on the beach. They build groynes to stop sand moving. The cliffs are eroding very quickly.) Level 2 (4 to 6 marks): Developed statements explaining how the coastal management strategies function to reduce erosion/flooding, or explaining the consequences of management. (e.g., Groynes built at Mappleton trap sand moved by longshore drift, which builds up a wide beach. This wide beach absorbs the energy of destructive waves, preventing them from directly eroding the weak clay cliffs behind. However, this has starved beaches downdrift of sediment, accelerating erosion elsewhere. Note: Max 5 marks if no named coastal area is given or if the example is inappropriate.) Level 3 (7 marks): Level 2 answers which include specific, detailed information about the chosen coastal area, including place-specific names, statistics, and details of the engineering projects. (e.g., Must include specific details such as Holderness, Mappleton, Withernsea, Great Cowden, B1242 road, Scandinavian granite, £2 million cost, or 2m/year erosion rates.)
Question 33 · case_study
7 marks
For a named area where tourism is important, explain how tourism has been managed to reduce its negative environmental and/or social impacts.
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
Example Case Study: Galapagos Islands, Ecuador. The Galapagos Islands are a fragile volcanic archipelago famous for unique species like the giant tortoise and marine iguana. Tourism numbers have increased dramatically, creating pressures like trail erosion, waste pollution, and the threat of invasive species. Management strategies: Strict visitor quotas are enforced by the Galapagos National Park Service, limiting the total annual number of tourists allowed to visit the islands to protect the delicate ecosystems from overcrowding. All tourists are required to be accompanied by a licensed Galapagos National Park guide at all times. Group sizes are limited to a maximum of 16 people per guide, ensuring that visitors stay on designated marked trails to prevent soil erosion and avoid disrupting the nesting sites of endemic birds like the blue-footed booby. To prevent the introduction of invasive species (such as fire ants, rats, or non-native seeds) which threaten endemic wildlife, strict biosecurity checks are conducted at airports on the mainland (Quito and Guayaquil) and on arrival in the islands using baggage X-rays and quarantine officers. A high entry fee of $100 USD (which is scheduled to increase to maintain sustainability) is charged to foreign tourists. This money is directly reinvested into park conservation, funding research at the Charles Darwin Research Station and paying for national park rangers to patrol the marine reserve.
Marking scheme
Level 1 (1 to 3 marks): Simple statements identifying negative impacts of tourism and/or basic management methods. (e.g., Tourism causes litter. They limit the number of tourists. Tourists have to pay a fee. They must stay on paths.) Level 2 (4 to 6 marks): Developed statements explaining how specific management strategies reduce the negative impacts on the environment or local society. (e.g., To prevent tourists from trampling on delicate vegetation and disturbing endemic nesting species like the marine iguana, all visitors must walk on designated raised wooden boardwalks and must be accompanied by a licensed national park guide who ensures they do not get too close to the wildlife. Note: Max 5 marks if no named tourism destination is given or if the example is inappropriate.) Level 3 (7 marks): Level 2 answers which include specific, detailed information about the chosen tourist destination, including place-specific names, specific species, statistics, and/or named conservation bodies. (e.g., Must include specific details such as the Galapagos Islands, Charles Darwin Research Station, $100 entry fee, Quito/Guayaquil, biosecurity measures, or specific endemic species like giant tortoises, blue-footed boobies, or marine iguanas.)
Paper 21 Geographical Skills
Answer all questions. You must use the 1:25000 topographic map extract, protractor, calculator, and ruler where appropriate.
6 Question · 60 marks
Question 1 · Geographical Skills
20 marks
Study the 1:25 000 map extract of Glenvale (Grid squares 3245 to 3750). The contour interval is 10 metres. Each grid square is 1 km by 1 km. Use the following key details for reference: 1. River Avill flows from south-west to north-east. 2. Public House (PH) is at 361 454. 3. Church with spire is at 338 467. 4. Oxbow lake is located at 342 478. 5. Triangulation pillar on Beacon Hill is at 340 490 (altitude 210m). 6. River crossing is at 340 460 (altitude 90m). Answer the following questions: Part (a) (i) Identify the 6-figure grid reference of the church with a spire in Glenvale. [2 marks] (ii) State the physical feature found at grid reference 342 478. [1 mark] (iii) Identify the human feature found at grid reference 361 454. [1 mark] Part (b) (i) Measure the straight-line distance in metres between the bridge over the River Avill at 334 462 and the road crossroad at 368 481. [2 marks] (ii) State the compass direction and measure the grid bearing from the bridge at 334 462 to the crossroad at 368 481. [2 marks] Part (c) (i) Describe the relief of the area in the northern half of the map extract (north of northing 48). [4 marks] (ii) Calculate the average gradient along the straight line from the triangulation pillar at Beacon Hill (340 490, height 210m) to the river crossing at 340 460 (height 90m). Show your working. [3 marks] Part (d) (i) Describe the distribution and layout of the settlement of Glenvale in grid square 3346. [3 marks] (ii) State two pieces of map evidence suggesting that the valley floor of the River Avill is prone to flooding. [2 marks]
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
Part (a) (i) The easting is 33 and the tenth value is 8. The northing is 46 and the tenth value is 7. Thus, 338 467. (ii) According to the key details, an oxbow lake is at 342 478. (iii) PH stands for Public House. Part (b) (i) The distance on the map is approximately 15.6 cm. At a scale of 1:25 000, 1 cm = 250 m. Therefore, 15.6 * 250 = 3900 m (calculated precisely using coordinates: \(\sqrt{3.4^2 + 1.9^2} = 3.89\) km = 3890 m). (ii) The direction from southwest to northeast is North-east (NE). The bearing is measured with a protractor as 61 degrees. Part (c) (i) The northern area features contours packed closely together indicating steep gradients, especially in the north-east around Beacon Hill (height 210m). The land drops rapidly towards the south where the contour lines space out. In the north-west, a river valley cuts through the high relief. (ii) Vertical Interval (VI) = 210m - 90m = 120m. Horizontal Equivalent (HE) = 3 grid squares north to south = 3 km = 3000m. Gradient = \(\frac{\text{VI}}{\text{HE}} = \frac{120}{3000} = \frac{1}{25}\) or 1 in 25 (0.04 or 4%). Part (d) (i) The houses are arranged linearly along the primary transport route. There is also a small cluster (nucleated layout) near the road intersection. The settlement avoids the immediate river channel, remaining on the slightly elevated northern side. (ii) Physical indicators of high flood hazard include the marsh/swamp symbol scattered across the valley floor, and the deliberate spatial layout of settlements keeping away from the low-lying river margins.
Marking scheme
Part (a) (i) Award 2 marks for exactly 338 467. Award 1 mark if one coordinate is off by 0.1 (e.g., 337 467 or 338 468). (ii) Award 1 mark for: Oxbow lake. (iii) Award 1 mark for: Public House / Inn / PH. Part (b) (i) Award 2 marks for a distance in the range of 3800m to 4000m. Award 1 mark for showing correct map distance of 15.2 to 16.0 cm. (ii) Award 1 mark for: North-east (NE) or East-north-east (ENE). Award 1 mark for bearing in the range of 59 to 63 degrees. Part (c) (i) Award up to 4 marks for descriptive points of the relief: Steep slopes (1 mark); High peak/Beacon Hill at 210m (1 mark); Slopes down to the south (1 mark); Valleys/spurs in the north-west (1 mark). (ii) Award 3 marks for full calculation: 1 mark for calculating correct height difference of 120m. 1 mark for calculating horizontal distance of 3000m. 1 mark for correct final gradient representation (1 in 25, 1:25, 0.04, or 4%). Part (d) (i) Award up to 3 marks for describing settlement pattern: Linear/along the road (1 mark); Nucleated at the junction (1 mark); Built on flat land/valley floor (1 mark); Avoids wet marsh areas / built on the north side (1 mark). (ii) Award 2 marks (1 mark per evidence point): Marsh/swamp symbols on the floodplain (1 mark); Roads/buildings set back from the river (1 mark).
Question 2 · thematic_skills_block
8 marks
Study the demographic data for two countries, Country X and Country Y. Country X has a Birth Rate of 42 per 1000, a Death Rate of 14 per 1000, Life Expectancy of 54 years, and a Population under 15 of 45 percent. Country Y has a Birth Rate of 10 per 1000, a Death Rate of 11 per 1000, Life Expectancy of 81 years, and a Population under 15 of 14 percent. (a) Identify which country is in Stage 2 of the Demographic Transition Model and give one reason for your choice. (2 marks) (b) Calculate the rate of natural population increase or decrease (as a percentage) for both Country X and Country Y. Show your working. (2 marks) (c) Using the data provided, describe the differences in the population structures of Country X and Country Y, and explain the social challenges Country Y might face as a result of its population structure. (4 marks)
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
(a) Country X is in Stage 2 because it has a high birth rate (42 per 1000) and a falling/moderate death rate (14 per 1000), which leads to rapid natural increase. (b) Natural increase rate = (Birth Rate - Death Rate) / 10. For Country X: (42 - 14) / 10 = 2.8 percent natural increase. For Country Y: (10 - 11) / 10 = -0.1 percent natural decrease. (c) Differences: Country X has a much younger population structure with 45 percent under 15 years compared to only 14 percent in Country Y. Country Y has a much longer life expectancy (81 years vs 54 years), indicating a higher proportion of elderly people. Challenges for Country Y include: shortage of future labor force, increased healthcare and nursing cost for the elderly, high dependency ratio, and potential closure of schools and maternity services due to low birth rates.
Marking scheme
(a) 1 mark for Country X. 1 mark for justifying with high birth rate (42 per 1000) or high gap between birth rate and death rate. (b) 1 mark for Country X calculation: (42-14)/10 = 2.8 percent (allow 28 per 1000). 1 mark for Country Y calculation: (10-11)/10 = -0.1 percent (allow -1 per 1000). (c) Max 2 marks for comparing structure: Country X has more young people/shorter life expectancy (or converse for Country Y). Max 2 marks for social challenges: pressure on pensions/healthcare, nursing home needs, underused schools, labor shortage. No credit for purely economic issues unless linked to social impact.
Question 3 · thematic_skills_block
8 marks
Study the details of three hypothetical earthquake events. Event Alpha: Magnitude 7.5, Depth of focus 8 km, Distance to nearest city 12 km, Building standards low. Event Beta: Magnitude 8.2, Depth of focus 95 km, Distance to nearest city 60 km, Building standards high. Event Gamma: Magnitude 6.1, Depth of focus 4 km, Distance to nearest city 3 km, Building standards moderate. (a) State which of the three events is likely to cause the greatest surface shaking in the nearest city and justify your choice. (2 marks) (b) Explain why Event Beta is likely to cause fewer casualties and less damage than Event Alpha, despite having a much higher magnitude. (3 marks) (c) Suggest three strategies, other than improving building design, that a city could implement to reduce the death toll from future earthquakes. (3 marks)
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
(a) Event Alpha (or Event Gamma). Justification for Alpha: High magnitude (7.5) combined with shallow depth (8 km) and close proximity (12 km) releases immense energy directly to the surface. Justification for Gamma: Extremely shallow depth (4 km) and extremely close proximity (3 km) mean seismic waves travel minimal distance to the city. (b) Event Beta has a much deeper focus (95 km vs 8 km) meaning seismic waves lose energy before reaching the surface; it is located much further away from the city (60 km vs 12 km); and it has high building standards which prevent structural collapse. (c) Strategies: 1. Implementing public education and regular earthquake drills; 2. Establishing emergency shelters and disaster response kits; 3. Planning land-use zoning to prevent high-density development on unstable soils/fault lines.
Marking scheme
(a) 1 mark for identifying Event Alpha (or Gamma). 1 mark for explanation: shallow focus/high magnitude/close proximity. (b) 1 mark for depth comparison (deep focus vs shallow focus). 1 mark for distance comparison (further away vs closer). 1 mark for building standards comparison (earthquake-resistant vs poor quality). (c) 1 mark per valid strategy: education/drills, early warning systems, land-use zoning, emergency rescue training, evacuation routes. Reject: building standards/materials (as excluded by prompt).
Question 4 · thematic_skills_block
8 marks
Study the following climate statistics. Station A: Mean monthly temperature range is 2 degrees Celsius (from 26 to 28 degrees Celsius); Total annual rainfall is 2450 mm; Minimum monthly rainfall is 120 mm. Station B: Mean monthly temperature range is 20 degrees Celsius (from 14 to 34 degrees Celsius); Total annual rainfall is 85 mm; Minimum monthly rainfall is 0 mm. (a) Identify the climate types shown at Station A and Station B. (2 marks) (b) State the annual temperature range for Station B. (1 mark) (c) Describe three distinct adaptations of natural vegetation to the climate conditions at Station B. (3 marks) (d) Explain why the daily (diurnal) temperature range is typically very high in the climate type shown at Station B. (2 marks)
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
(a) Station A is Equatorial (or Tropical Rainforest) climate because it is hot and wet all year with a very low temperature range. Station B is a Hot Desert climate because it is arid (low rainfall) with a high temperature range. (b) The annual temperature range for Station B is 20 degrees Celsius. (c) Vegetation adaptations in a hot desert (Station B): 1. Succulent (fleshy) stems or leaves to store water; 2. Very deep/long tap roots to reach low water tables, or wide shallow roots to catch surface dew; 3. Spines/needles instead of leaves to reduce transpiration and prevent consumption by animals; 4. Thick waxy cuticles to prevent water loss. (d) Diurnal temperature range is high because of the lack of cloud cover. During the day, there are no clouds to block incoming solar radiation, leading to intense heating. At night, the lack of clouds allows heat (longwave radiation) to rapidly escape back into space, leading to rapid cooling.
Marking scheme
(a) 1 mark for Station A (Equatorial/Tropical Rainforest). 1 mark for Station B (Hot Desert). (b) 1 mark for 20 degrees Celsius (accept 20). (c) 1 mark per adaptation described: tap roots, shallow wide roots, succulence/water storage, spikes/thorns, waxy leaves, dormant seeds. (Max 3). (d) 1 mark for explaining daytime heating (lack of clouds allows solar radiation in). 1 mark for explaining nighttime cooling (lack of clouds allows longwave radiation/heat to escape).
Question 5 · thematic_skills_block
8 marks
Study the agricultural system described in this statement: A farm in East Anglia, UK, has large fields of wheat and barley. High amounts of chemical fertilizers, pesticides, and modern combine harvesters are used. The labor force is small, consisting of the owner and two full-time employees. All crops are sold to national supermarket chains for profit. (a) Classify this farming system by choosing the correct terms from the following pairs: (i) Arable or Pastoral, (ii) Intensive or Extensive, (iii) Commercial or Subsistence. (3 marks) (b) Using the description, identify: (i) Two human inputs. (2 marks) (ii) One output. (1 mark) (c) Explain how two different human inputs mentioned in the text increase the crop yields on this farm. (2 marks)
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
(a) (i) Arable (crops are grown). (ii) Intensive (high capital/chemical inputs per hectare). (iii) Commercial (sold to supermarkets for profit). (b) (i) Human inputs mentioned: chemical fertilizers, pesticides, combine harvesters, labor (owner and two employees). (Accept any two). (ii) Outputs: wheat or barley. (c) Fertilizers increase crop yields by adding essential soil nutrients (like nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium) which promote faster and healthier plant growth. Pesticides increase yields by killing insects/pests that would otherwise damage, eat, or destroy the crops.
Marking scheme
(a) 1 mark for Arable. 1 mark for Intensive. 1 mark for Commercial. (b) (i) 1 mark per input identified from the text: chemical fertilizers, pesticides, combine harvesters, labor/owner/employees. (Max 2). (ii) 1 mark for wheat OR barley. (c) 1 mark for explaining fertilizer impact (nutrients/soil fertility/growth). 1 mark for explaining pesticide impact (kills pests/prevents damage to crops).
Question 6 · thematic_skills_block
8 marks
Study the channel measurements taken at two sites along a river: Site 1 (Upper Course): Channel Width = 3.0 m, Mean Depth = 0.4 m, Average Velocity = 0.5 m/s. Site 2 (Lower Course): Channel Width = 12.0 m, Mean Depth = 2.0 m, Average Velocity = 1.5 m/s. (a) Calculate the cross-sectional area of the river channel at Site 1. Show your working. (2 marks) (b) Calculate the river discharge (using the formula: Discharge = Cross-sectional Area multiplied by Velocity) at Site 2. State the unit of measurement in your answer. (2 marks) (c) Describe how the channel dimensions change from Site 1 to Site 2, and explain why the velocity increases downstream. (4 marks)
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
(a) Cross-sectional area = Width multiplied by Depth = 3.0 m multiplied by 0.4 m = 1.2 square meters. (b) Cross-sectional area at Site 2 = 12.0 m multiplied by 2.0 m = 24.0 square meters. Discharge = Area multiplied by Velocity = 24.0 square meters multiplied by 1.5 m/s = 36 cubic meters per second (cumecs). (c) Changes in channel dimensions: The channel becomes wider (from 3 m to 12 m) and deeper (from 0.4 m to 2.0 m) downstream. Reasons for velocity increase downstream: 1. Increased discharge/volume of water from tributaries; 2. Channel becomes smoother and more efficient, reducing friction against the river bed and banks; 3. Larger proportion of water is not in contact with the bed/banks, reducing drag.
Marking scheme
(a) 1 mark for correct working (3.0 x 0.4). 1 mark for correct calculation (1.2 square meters / m2). (b) 1 mark for correct calculation of discharge (36). 1 mark for correct unit (cubic meters per second / m3/s / cumecs). (c) 1 mark for describing changes: wider and deeper downstream. Max 3 marks for reasons: increase in volume/discharge, less friction/smoother channel, higher hydraulic efficiency/lower wetted perimeter relative to area.
Paper 41 Alternative to Coursework
Answer all questions. The paper tests the techniques of geographic investigation, fieldwork data presentation, and critical analysis.
3 Question · 90 marks
Question 1 · Fieldwork Analysis
30 marks
A group of Geography students from an international school in Chengdu, China, conducted a fieldwork investigation in the pedestrianized commercial zone of Sichuan Plaza. The commercial zone has recently been redeveloped to restrict motor vehicle traffic and prioritize shoppers. The students wanted to investigate two hypotheses: Hypothesis 1: 'The environmental quality of the commercial zone improves with distance away from the main arterial ring road.' Hypothesis 2: 'The pedestrian footfall decreases as distance from the nearest Metro (subway) station entrance increases.' Part (a)(i): Suggest two safety precautions the students should take when conducting pedestrian counts and surveys near busy urban streets. (2 marks) Part (a)(ii): Describe how the students would carry out a systematic sampling method to select 5 survey sites along a 250-meter transect starting from the Metro station entrance. (3 marks) Part (b)(i): The students recorded pedestrian counts at their 5 selected sites (A to E) at three different times of the day (08:30, 13:00, and 18:00) for 10 minutes. Why is it important to measure pedestrian flow at different times of the day? (2 marks) Part (b)(ii): The results of the pedestrian count are as follows: Site A (50m from metro): 08:30 (120 people), 13:00 (180 people), 18:00 (240 people), Total = 540. Site B (100m): 08:30 (95 people), 13:00 (140 people), 18:00 (195 people), Total = 430. Site C (150m): 08:30 (70 people), 13:00 (110 people), 18:00 (150 people), Total = 330. Site D (200m): 08:30 (50 people), 13:00 (85 people), 18:00 (115 people), Total = 250. Site E (250m): 08:30 (35 people), 13:00 (60 people), 18:00 (85 people), Total = 180. Describe the patterns shown by this pedestrian flow data. Support your answer with data from the sites. (4 marks) Part (b)(iii): Explain why pedestrian density is typically highest closest to a transit hub like a Metro station entrance. (3 marks) Part (c)(i): To test Hypothesis 1, the students used an Environmental Quality Survey (EQS) sheet scoring five categories (noise, air quality, litter, visual aesthetics, and green spaces) on a bipolar scale from -2 to +2 (overall score ranging from -10 to +10). State two advantages and two disadvantages of using an EQS to assess environmental quality. (4 marks) Part (c)(ii): The total EQS scores recorded by the students at varying distances from the main arterial ring road were: 0m (closest to road): -6; 50m: -2; 100m: +3; 150m: +6; 200m: +8. Write a conclusion for Hypothesis 1. Support your decision with specific evidence from the EQS results. (4 marks) Part (d): Suggest three ways the students could improve the reliability and accuracy of their data if they were to repeat this investigation. (3 marks) Part (e): To further analyze the commercial characteristics of the Sichuan Plaza area, suggest how the students could design and carry out a land-use mapping survey to record the types of shops and services present. (5 marks)
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
Part (a)(i): Safety precautions include: 1) Wear high-visibility jackets or clothing so drivers can spot them easily. 2) Work in groups of 3 to 4, keeping an eye out for potential hazards and never stepping off the sidewalk/curb. Part (a)(ii): Systematic sampling method: 1) Lay out a 250m transect line using a GIS map or tape measure. 2) Choose a fixed, regular interval of 50 meters. 3) Select the exact points at 50m (Site A), 100m (Site B), 150m (Site C), 200m (Site D), and 250m (Site E) to avoid subjective bias. Part (b)(i): Measuring at different times is important because: 1) Urban pedestrian flows fluctuate dynamically throughout the day due to commuting patterns (rush hours), lunch breaks, and evening leisure shopping. 2) Taking multiple measurements ensures a representative average and avoids temporary anomalies. Part (b)(ii): Data analysis: The pedestrian flow decreases steadily as distance from the Metro station increases. Site A (closest at 50m) has the highest footfall with a total of 540 people, whereas Site E (furthest at 250m) has the lowest total of 180 people. This negative correlation is consistent across all times of day. For example, at 18:00, pedestrian counts drop from 240 at Site A to 85 at Site E. Part (b)(iii): Highest density near Metro because: 1) High accessibility as the Metro acts as a major public transport gateway delivering thousands of shoppers directly into the area. 2) Convenience and friction of distance, as commuters and shoppers prefer to access immediate facilities without walking long distances. 3) Retail clustering of high-order convenience services and anchor department stores near transit exits to capture maximum impulse buying. Part (c)(i): Advantages of EQS: 1) Quick, cheap, and simple to carry out on-site. 2) Provides quantitative scores which can be easily graphed and compared. Disadvantages of EQS: 1) Highly subjective as different students may score the same environment differently. 2) Represents only a single snapshot in time (e.g., temporary noise from a passing siren can skew results). Part (c)(ii): Hypothesis 1 is fully supported (correct). The data shows a clear, positive relationship where environmental quality increases as distance from the arterial ring road increases. At 0m (adjacent to the road), the EQS score is very poor at -6. The scores turn positive at 100m (+3) and reach a peak quality score of +8 at 200m distance. Part (d): Improvements: 1) Use objective scientific equipment (e.g., digital decibel meters for noise, PM2.5 sensors for air quality). 2) Repeat the survey over multiple days (e.g., weekdays and weekends) to calculate a more robust mean. 3) Have multiple independent student groups score the same sites and take the average score to minimize subjectivity. Part (e): Land-use survey design: 1) Obtain a detailed large-scale base map of Sichuan Plaza. 2) Create a standardized functional classification key (e.g., convenience shops, comparison shops, food and beverage, financial services, offices, vacant units). 3) Systematically walk along both sides of the streets, identifying the function of each ground-floor unit. 4) Use color-coding or abbreviations to record each category directly onto the base map in real-time. 5) Note vertical zoning by recording upper-floor uses where possible.
Marking scheme
Part (a)(i) [2 marks]: 1 mark per valid safety precaution. Accept: high-visibility clothing, staying on pedestrian areas, working in pairs/groups, carrying mobile phones. Reject: 'be careful' (too vague). Part (a)(ii) [3 marks]: 1 mark for calculating/stating the regular interval (50m). 1 mark for describing the transect alignment from the Metro starting point. 1 mark for explaining how bias is eliminated by sticking strictly to the pre-determined points. Part (b)(i) [2 marks]: 1 mark for identifying temporal variations/rush hours/lunch periods. 1 mark for linking this to obtaining a representative/reliable average. Part (b)(ii) [4 marks]: 1 mark for identifying the general trend (negative correlation/decrease with distance). 1 mark for identifying the highest point with data (Site A, 540 total). 1 mark for identifying the lowest point with data (Site E, 180 total). 1 mark for demonstrating the trend at a specific time (e.g., 18:00 drops from 240 to 85). Part (b)(iii) [3 marks]: 1 mark for the concept of accessibility/nodal point. 1 mark for consumer convenience/unwillingness to walk far (friction of distance). 1 mark for land-use competition/retailers maximizing footfall near the exit. Part (c)(i) [4 marks]: 1 mark per valid advantage (max 2) and 1 mark per valid disadvantage (max 2). Advantages: easy comparison, quantitative scores, covers multiple environmental elements. Disadvantages: highly subjective, weather/temporary conditions can distort results, lacks physical scientific precision. Part (c)(ii) [4 marks]: 1 mark for stating that the hypothesis is fully supported/true. 1 mark for stating that environmental quality improves with distance away from the road. 2 marks for using specific, accurate paired data (e.g., -6 at 0m versus +8 at 200m). Part (d) [3 marks]: 1 mark per valid improvement. Accept: use digital measuring instruments (decibel meters), repeat on different days (weekdays vs. weekends), increase the number of sample sites, average scores across multiple student groups to reduce bias. Part (e) [5 marks]: 1 mark for obtaining/using a base map of the area. 1 mark for designing/using a functional category key (retail, leisure, etc.). 1 mark for systematic walking/coverage of both sides of the street. 1 mark for plotting/color-coding onto the map in real-time. 1 mark for noting vertical land-use (upper floors).
Question 2 · Fieldwork Analysis
30 marks
### Coastal Processes and Management at Barton Sands
A group of geography students investigated coastal processes and coastal management along the sandy beach at Barton Sands. The coastline is subject to strong prevailing winds from the south-west, causing significant longshore drift.
The students wanted to investigate the following hypotheses: * **Hypothesis 1:** *The rate of longshore drift is greater on the unprotected western stretch of the beach than on the eastern stretch protected by wooden groynes.* * **Hypothesis 2:** *The beach profile is steeper and sediment size is larger at the managed eastern beach (Site B) compared to the unmanaged western beach (Site A).*
**(a)** Describe a fieldwork method the students could use to measure the rate and direction of longshore drift. [5]
**(b)** Explain how wooden groynes prevent the movement of beach material by longshore drift. [3]
**(c)** To investigate Hypothesis 2, the students measured the beach profile and sediment size at Site A (unprotected) and Site B (protected). (i) Name two pieces of equipment the students would use to measure the beach profile. [2] (ii) Explain how the students would measure the slope angle of the beach at regular intervals from the low water mark to the back of the beach. [4]
**(d)** The results of the students' sediment size and beach slope measurements are shown in the table below:
| Distance from Low Water Mark (m) | Site A (Unprotected): Average Sediment Size (mm) | Site A (Unprotected): Beach Slope Angle (°) | Site B (Protected): Average Sediment Size (mm) | Site B (Protected): Beach Slope Angle (°) | |---|---|---|---|---| | 0 | 2 | 2 | 5 | 3 | | 5 | 3 | 2 | 8 | 4 | | 10 | 5 | 3 | 14 | 6 | | 15 | 8 | 4 | 22 | 9 | | 20 | 12 | 5 | 35 | 12 | | 25 | 18 | 6 | 48 | 15 |
(i) Using the data table, what conclusion can the students make regarding **Hypothesis 2**? Support your answer with evidence from the table. [3] (ii) Describe the relationship between sediment size and beach slope angle shown by the data at both sites. [2]
**(e)** Explain why sediment size generally increases with distance from the low water mark towards the back of the beach. [4]
**(f)** The students decided to conduct a questionnaire with local residents to gather opinions on the coastal management scheme. (i) Describe how the students could use a **systematic sampling** method to select 50 residents to interview. [3] (ii) State two disadvantages of using a questionnaire to assess local opinions on coastal management. [2]
**(g)** Suggest two ways the students could improve the reliability and accuracy of their fieldwork data if they repeated this investigation. [2]
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
### Detailed Solution & Answers
**(a) Fieldwork method to measure longshore drift [5 marks]:** 1. Lay out a tape measure of a fixed distance (e.g., 10 metres) along the shoreline parallel to the beach. 2. Place a floating object that is highly visible and semi-submerged (e.g., an orange or tennis ball) into the water where the waves break. 3. Start a stopwatch as soon as the float is released. 4. Record the time taken (in seconds) for the float to travel the 10-metre distance. 5. Observe and record the direction of travel (e.g., west to east) to confirm the direction of longshore drift. 6. Repeat the test 3 to 5 times and calculate the average speed using the formula: \(\text{Speed} = \frac{\text{Distance}}{\text{Average Time}}\).
**(b) How wooden groynes prevent the movement of beach material [3 marks]:** 1. Groynes are built at right angles (90 degrees) to the shoreline. 2. They act as physical barriers that block or intercept sediment moving parallel to the beach. 3. This traps sand and pebbles on the updrift side (facing the direction of longshore drift), preventing it from being transported further down the coast, thereby building up the beach.
**(c)(i) Equipment to measure beach profile [2 marks]:** * Ranging poles (two required) * Clinometer * Tape measure (any two of these for the marks)
**(c)(ii) How to measure slope angle [4 marks]:** 1. Place the first ranging pole vertically at the low water mark and the second ranging pole at a set distance (e.g., 5 metres) or at a break of slope further up the beach. 2. Ensure the tape measure is laid flat on the ground to measure the horizontal distance between the poles. 3. One student holds the clinometer at a designated, marked height on the first ranging pole (such as eye-level or a specific marker band). 4. Sight through the clinometer to the exact corresponding height mark on the second ranging pole. 5. Read and record the angle of the slope in degrees from the clinometer scale. 6. Repeat this process for each subsequent segment of the beach profile up to the back of the beach.
**(d)(i) Conclusion for Hypothesis 2 [3 marks]:** * **Hypothesis 2 is supported/correct.** * Site B (the protected beach) has larger sediment sizes and steeper slope angles at all points compared to Site A (unprotected). * **Data support:** At 25m from the low water mark, the sediment size at Site B is 48 mm and the beach slope angle is 15°, whereas at Site A the sediment size is only 18 mm and the beach slope angle is 6°.
**(d)(ii) Relationship between sediment size and slope [2 marks]:** * There is a positive correlation / direct relationship between sediment size and beach slope angle. * As the average sediment size increases, the beach slope angle becomes steeper (e.g., at Site B, as sediment size increases from 5 mm to 48 mm, the slope angle increases from 3° to 15°).
**(e) Why sediment size increases towards the back of the beach [4 marks]:** 1. Large, heavy sediments (pebbles/shingle) are transported and deposited high up the beach (storm beach) by high-energy constructive waves or storm waves during high tide. 2. The strong swash has enough energy to carry all sizes of sediment up the beach. 3. However, the weaker backwash loses energy as water infiltrates into the porous sand and shingle; therefore, it can only transport smaller, lighter particles back down towards the sea. 4. Near the low water mark, constant wave action causes attrition (particles rubbing against each other), which rapidly breaks down and rounds the sediment into smaller sizes.
**(f)(i) Systematic sampling of 50 residents [3 marks]:** 1. Determine a regular sampling interval, such as choosing every 5th or 10th person who passes by. 2. Select a high-footfall location near the coastal defences (e.g., the beach promenade or visitor centre) at a consistent time of day. 3. Stand at this spot and approach every \(n\)-th person to ask them to fill out the questionnaire until a total of 50 responses is gathered. 4. This ensures an unbiased selection as it avoids selecting people based on subjective appearance.
**(f)(ii) Disadvantages of questionnaires [2 marks]:** * People may refuse to participate, leading to small, unrepresentative, or biased samples. * Answers are subjective and based on personal opinion, which may not reflect physical geographical facts. * Language barriers or misunderstandings of technical terms (e.g., "groynes") can lead to inaccurate answers.
**(g) Two ways to improve reliability [2 marks]:** * Repeat the measurements on different days, seasons, or tidal states to account for changing conditions. * Increase the number of sample sites along both stretches of the beach (e.g., measure 5 sites instead of just 2). * Measure a larger sample size of pebbles (e.g., 20 pebbles instead of just a few) at each point to get a more accurate average size.
Marking scheme
**(a) Fieldwork method for longshore drift (Max 5 marks):** * 1 mark for laying out a measured distance / tape measure (e.g., 10m). * 1 mark for using a visible float (e.g., orange/tennis ball). * 1 mark for timing with a stopwatch. * 1 mark for recording direction of movement. * 1 mark for repeating the process (3-5 times) to calculate an average.
**(b) Wooden groynes mechanism (Max 3 marks):** * 1 mark for stating groynes are built perpendicular / 90° to the coast. * 1 mark for explaining that they trap/block sediment carried by longshore drift. * 1 mark for explaining that this builds up/widens the updrift beach.
**(c)(i) Equipment (Max 2 marks):** * 1 mark for ranging poles. * 1 mark for clinometer (accept tape measure if ranging poles or clinometer is missing).
**(c)(ii) Measuring slope angle (Max 4 marks):** * 1 mark for placing ranging poles at a measured distance / break of slope. * 1 mark for identifying the need to sight to the same height on both poles. * 1 mark for sighting using a clinometer. * 1 mark for reading and recording the angle in degrees.
**(d)(i) Conclusion and evidence (Max 3 marks):** * 1 mark for stating Hypothesis 2 is correct / supported. * 1 mark for stating Site B has both steeper slopes and larger sediment than Site A. * 1 mark for providing paired comparative data from the table (must include distance, site, and values with units).
**(d)(ii) Relationship (Max 2 marks):** * 1 mark for identifying the positive correlation / direct relationship. * 1 mark for supporting with paired data showing that as sediment size increases, slope angle increases.
**(e) Why sediment size increases towards the back of the beach (Max 4 marks):** * 1 mark for identifying that constructive/storm waves carry large material to the back of the beach. * 1 mark for explaining that strong swash transports all material up. * 1 mark for explaining that weak backwash cannot transport large material back down (loss of energy through percolation). * 1 mark for mentioning attrition reducing sediment size near the low water mark.
**(f)(i) Systematic sampling (Max 3 marks):** * 1 mark for describing the interval rule (e.g., choosing every 5th person). * 1 mark for explaining where to stand (high footfall area / promenade). * 1 mark for explaining that this process is repeated until 50 people are reached to avoid personal selection bias.
**(f)(ii) Disadvantages of questionnaires (Max 2 marks):** * 1 mark per disadvantage (e.g., citizen bias/subjectivity, refusal to participate, misunderstandings of questions).
**(g) Improvements (Max 2 marks):** * 1 mark per valid improvement (e.g., repeat over different seasons/tides, increase sample size of pebbles, use more sample sites).
Question 3 · Fieldwork Analysis
30 marks
Placeholder question to match expected structure
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
Placeholder
Marking scheme
Placeholder
Wondering how well you actually know this?
Thinka is an AI practice app for DSE students — unlimited questions, instant auto-marking, and detailed step-by-step solutions. 100,000+ students use it to confirm they actually know it, not just think they do.