Cambridge IGCSE · Thinka-original Practice Paper

2025 Cambridge IGCSE Geography (0460) Practice Paper with Answers

Thinka Nov 2025 (V2) Cambridge International A Level-Style Mock — Geography (0460)

270 marks285 mins2025
An original Thinka practice paper modelled on the structure and difficulty of the Nov 2025 (V2) Cambridge International A Level Geography (0460) paper. Not affiliated with or reproduced from Cambridge.

Paper 12 (Themes)

Answer three questions in total, one from each section (Population, Natural Environment, Economic Development).
6 Question · 150 marks
Question 1 · structured-essay
25 marks
Theme 1: Population and Settlement

Question 1
(a) (i) Define the term immigration. [1]
(ii) Give two social push factors that might cause people to migrate. [2]
(iii) Explain how a country's physical environment can act as a push factor. [3]
(iv) Describe the potential positive impacts of immigration on the destination country. [4]

(b) (i) Explain how economic factors act as pull factors for international migration. [3]
(ii) Explain the challenges faced by migrants when they arrive in their destination country. [5]

(c) For a named international migration route you have studied, explain the causes of the migration and its impacts on the source country. [7]
Show answer & marking scheme

Worked solution

(a) (i) Immigration is the movement of people into a foreign country to live there permanently.
(ii) Two social push factors: 1. Escape from war, civil conflict, or persecution. 2. Lack of educational or medical facilities in the home area.
(iii) Physical environments act as push factors through natural hazards (e.g., active volcanoes, frequent earthquakes, or severe hurricanes) which destroy homes and infrastructure; prolonged drought or desertification making agriculture impossible; or rising sea levels and flooding in low-lying coastal areas.
(iv) Positive impacts of immigration on destination countries include: filling gaps in the labor market (both low-skilled and highly skilled jobs); paying taxes which contribute to public services; introducing new cultures, languages, and food (cultural enrichment); and helping to offset the effects of an aging population or low birth rates.

(b) (i) Economic pull factors include: higher wages and better paying jobs than in the source country; a greater abundance and variety of job opportunities; and the prospect of a higher standard of living or greater wealth.
(ii) Migrants face many challenges upon arrival, such as: language barriers which make communication and finding employment difficult; discrimination, prejudice, or social isolation; difficulty securing legal status, work permits, or formal documentation; expensive or poor-quality housing, often in segregated areas; and challenges in accessing essential public services like healthcare and schooling.

(c) Case study: Migration from Mexico to the USA.
Causes: Higher average wages in the USA (e.g., in agriculture, construction, and hospitality) compared to lower wages and high unemployment rates in rural Mexico. Push factors in Mexico include rural poverty, high crime rates associated with drug cartels, and limited access to secondary education. Pull factors include the presence of established family networks in the USA and better educational opportunities.
Impacts on the source country (Mexico): Positive impacts include billions of dollars in remittances sent home annually, which improves family living standards and funds local businesses or schools. However, negative impacts include a 'brain drain' and loss of young, working-age males, leaving behind an aging population and a gender imbalance in rural villages.

Marking scheme

(a) (i) 1 mark for a correct definition: movement of people into a country to live.
(ii) 2 marks (1 mark per valid social push factor: e.g., persecution, war, lack of health facilities, religious intolerance).
(iii) 3 marks (1 mark per point / developed point): e.g., natural disasters like volcanic eruptions destroy housing [1]; droughts lead to crop failure and famine [1]; flooding makes lands uninhabitable [1].
(iv) 4 marks (1 mark per valid impact described): e.g., supply of cheap labor [1], fills labor shortages [1], pays taxes [1], cultural diversity [1], offsets aging population [1].

(b) (i) 3 marks (1 mark per economic pull factor explained): e.g., job vacancies in key industries [1], high wage rates compared to home country [1], chance of a higher standard of living [1].
(ii) 5 marks (1 mark per explained challenge): e.g., language barrier limits jobs [1], exploitation by employers due to lack of rights [1], high cost of living [1], social exclusion/racism [1], substandard living conditions/slums [1].

(c) Case Study Level-of-Response Marking:
Level 1 (1-3 marks): Simple statements explaining causes/impacts of migration in general terms, without specific place details (e.g., 'people move for money and send back cash').
Level 2 (4-6 marks): Developed statements explaining causes and impacts, with some specific details or names linked to the chosen route (e.g., 'Mexicans move to the USA to work in farms in California; they send remittances back to rural villages like Jalisco to build schools').
Level 3 (7 marks): Fully developed, detailed explanation covering both causes and impacts on the source country, with precise place-specific details and statistical support.
Question 2 · structured-essay
25 marks
Theme 1: Population and Settlement

Question 2
(a) (i) Define the term Central Business District (CBD). [1]
(ii) State two features of the CBD's land use. [2]
(iii) Explain why land value varies from the CBD to the rural-urban fringe. [3]
(iv) Describe the problems associated with rapid urban growth in the rural-urban fringe. [4]

(b) (i) Describe how urban planners can reduce traffic congestion in major cities. [3]
(ii) Explain why living in informal settlements (shanty towns) in LICs can present health and environmental risks to residents. [5]

(c) For a named city you have studied, explain the strategies used to manage the challenges of urban growth. [7]
Show answer & marking scheme

Worked solution

(a) (i) The Central Business District (CBD) is the commercial, retail, and business core of an urban area, characterized by high accessibility.
(ii) Two features of the CBD: 1. High concentration of department stores, offices, and banks. 2. High density of high-rise buildings (vertical development) due to expensive land.
(iii) Land value is highest in the CBD because of high accessibility and competition for limited space. As distance from the CBD increases, land values decrease because the land is less accessible to shoppers/workers and there is a larger supply of available open land towards the rural-urban fringe.
(iv) Problems at the rural-urban fringe include: loss of productive agricultural land and open green space (greenfields); increased traffic congestion from commuters; loss of natural habitats; and aesthetic/visual pollution from sprawling suburban estates or retail parks.

(b) (i) Planners can reduce congestion by: expanding public transport networks (e.g., bus rapid transit or metro lines); introducing congestion charges or high parking fees in the city center; and building ring roads/bypasses to divert through-traffic away from the core.
(ii) Informal settlements present severe health and environmental risks because: a lack of piped clean water leads to waterborne diseases like cholera; a lack of sewage systems results in human waste polluting local rivers and ground water; poor waste disposal leads to piles of garbage attracting disease-carrying pests like rats; structures are built on steep, unstable slopes prone to landslides during heavy rain; and high housing density with flammable materials increases the risk of rapidly spreading fires.

(c) Case study: Curitiba, Brazil.
Strategies used to manage urban growth: Curitiba implemented an integrated Bus Rapid Transit (BRT) system using triple-articulated buses and dedicated express lanes, which significantly reduced transit times and emissions. To manage waste, the 'Green Exchange' program was launched, where residents in favelas trade sorted garbage for food or bus tokens, keeping the city clean and improving nutrition. Curitiba also preserved flood-prone lowlands as parks rather than building concrete channels, preventing urban flooding while creating recreational spaces.

Marking scheme

(a) (i) 1 mark for correct definition: commercial center/heart of the city [1].
(ii) 2 marks (1 mark per valid feature): high-rise buildings [1], high density of shops/offices [1], lack of residential housing [1], pedestrianised zones [1].
(iii) 3 marks (1 mark per point): CBD has highest demand/competition [1], CBD is highly accessible [1], further away there is more land available which lowers the price per square meter [1].
(iv) 4 marks (1 mark per valid problem described): urban sprawl destroys farmland [1], habitat loss [1], traffic pollution on commuter routes [1], loss of rural character/identity [1].

(b) (i) 3 marks (1 mark per described transport management strategy): park and ride schemes [1], dedicated cycle lanes [1], investment in metro/buses [1], car-pooling lanes [1].
(ii) 5 marks (1 mark per hazard explained): open sewers spread cholera [1], mudslides kill residents on steep hills [1], lack of trash collection breeds vermin [1], toxic fumes from open fires/stoves [1], fast-spreading fires due to wooden/corrugated iron materials [1].

(c) Case Study Level-of-Response Marking:
Level 1 (1-3 marks): Simple descriptions of generic strategies to solve city problems (e.g., 'they built more buses and cleaned up trash').
Level 2 (4-6 marks): Developed explanations of specific named strategies within a chosen city (e.g., 'Curitiba used BRT bus tubes and the Green Exchange program to trade garbage for food').
Level 3 (7 marks): Fully detailed, comprehensive case study analysis with specific place details, quantitative evidence, and high-quality geographical explanation of multiple successful strategies.
Question 3 · structured-essay
25 marks
Theme 2: The Natural Environment

Question 3
(a) (i) Identify the type of plate boundary where tectonic plates slide past each other horizontally. [1]
(ii) Describe two processes that occur at a convergent (destructive) plate boundary where an oceanic plate meets a continental plate. [2]
(iii) Explain why earthquakes of high magnitude often occur along convergent plate boundaries. [3]
(iv) Explain how earthquakes can cause secondary hazards such as tsunamis and landslides. [4]

(b) (i) Describe three ways in which volcanic eruptions can benefit people living nearby. [3]
(ii) Explain how a country can prepare for and reduce the impacts of a volcanic eruption. [5]

(c) For a named earthquake or volcanic eruption you have studied, explain the causes and consequences of the hazard. [7]
Show answer & marking scheme

Worked solution

(a) (i) Conservative (or transform) plate boundary.
(ii) Two processes: 1. Subduction: the denser oceanic plate is forced downwards into the mantle beneath the lighter continental plate. 2. Melting: the subducted plate melts due to high heat and friction in the asthenosphere, forming magma.
(iii) High-magnitude earthquakes occur because the subducting plate gets stuck against the overriding continental plate due to friction. This buildup of massive friction and pressure (elastic strain) over time is suddenly released when the rocks fracture, releasing immense seismic energy.
(iv) Earthquakes generate tsunamis when an underwater fault ruptures, displacing the water column above and creating massive, fast-traveling ocean waves. Landslides are triggered when strong ground shaking destabilizes soil, rocks, and mud on steep slopes, causing them to collapse and slide downhill under gravity.

(b) (i) Benefits of volcanic eruptions: 1. Weathered volcanic ash and lava create highly fertile soil rich in nutrients, excellent for farming. 2. Geothermal energy can be harnessed from the underground heat to generate electricity. 3. Volcanic landforms and hot springs attract tourists, creating local jobs and revenue.
(ii) Preparation and reduction strategies: monitoring the volcano using seismometers, gas spectrometers, and tiltmeters to predict eruptions; establishing clear evacuation routes and exclusion zones; educating the public with emergency drills; stocking emergency shelters with food, water, and masks; and designing buildings with sloped, reinforced roofs to prevent collapse from heavy ash accumulation.

(c) Case study: Mt. Merapi Volcanic Eruption, Indonesia (2010).
Causes: Mt. Merapi is located on a convergent (destructive) plate boundary where the Indo-Australian Plate subducts beneath the Eurasian (Sunda) Plate. As the subducting plate melted, highly viscous, silica-rich gas-pressurized magma rose to the surface, causing explosive eruptions.
Consequences: Pyroclastic flows traveled down the slopes, destroying villages like Bronggang and killing over 350 people. Volcanic ash forced the evacuation of over 350,000 residents and disrupted local aviation across Southeast Asia. Farmland was covered in thick ash layers, destroying crops and livestock, leading to immediate economic losses, although in the long term, it restored soil fertility.

Marking scheme

(a) (i) 1 mark: Conservative / transform boundary.
(ii) 2 marks (1 mark per process described): Subduction (oceanic plate sinks under continental) [1], melting of the subducting plate [1], or friction/sticking of plates [1].
(iii) 3 marks (1 mark per explanatory point): Friction holds plates together [1], pressure/strain builds up over time [1], sudden release of energy when plates slip [1].
(iv) 4 marks (2 marks for tsunami explanation, 2 marks for landslide explanation): Displacement of ocean water by fault movement [1], generation of deep-water waves that grow as they reach coast [1]; Ground shaking destabilizes slope [1], gravity pulls loose rock/soil down [1].

(b) (i) 3 marks (1 mark per benefit): Fertile volcanic soils [1], geothermal power [1], tourism/scenery [1], mining of sulfur/precious minerals [1].
(ii) 5 marks (1 mark per explained strategy): Monitoring gases/seismic activity [1], evacuation mapping [1], exclusion zones [1], public education/drills [1], emergency supplies/shelters [1], reinforced building roofs [1].

(c) Case Study Level-of-Response Marking:
Level 1 (1-3 marks): Simple descriptions of why a hazard occurred or what happened, with generic statements (e.g., 'plates crashed together and many people died and houses burned').
Level 2 (4-6 marks): Developed explanations showing understanding of the causes (subducting plate boundary names) and detailed consequences (deaths, economic losses, specific details of the named event).
Level 3 (7 marks): Comprehensive, fully developed response with precise details of the named volcano/earthquake (e.g., Mt. Merapi 2010), including plate names, exact casualties/impact statistics, and clear spatial/consequential links.
Question 4 · structured-essay
25 marks
Theme 2: The Natural Environment

Question 4
(a) (i) What is meant by the term river discharge? [1]
(ii) State two methods of river transport. [2]
(iii) Describe how a river's channel characteristics change from its source to its mouth. [3]
(iv) Explain how a waterfall is formed. [4]

(b) (i) Explain how human activities within a river basin can increase the risk of flooding. [3]
(ii) Explain how soft engineering methods can be used to manage river flooding. [5]

(c) For a named river you have studied, explain the opportunities it provides for people and the hazards it presents. [7]
Show answer & marking scheme

Worked solution

(a) (i) River discharge is the volume of water flowing through a river channel past a given point per unit of time, usually measured in cubic meters per second (cumecs).
(ii) Two methods of river transport: 1. Traction (rolling of large stones along the river bed). 2. Suspension (fine sediment carried in the water flow).
(iii) From source to mouth, a river's channel becomes: 1. Wider as lateral erosion takes over. 2. Deeper as discharge increases and more load is eroded. 3. Smoother with less friction, because bedload is smaller and more rounded.
(iv) Waterfalls form when a river flows over a band of hard (resistant) rock overlying soft (less resistant) rock. The river erodes the soft rock faster through hydraulic action and abrasion, creating a step. As water plunges over the step, a plunge pool forms at the base. Undercutting of the hard rock occurs until it collapses, causing the waterfall to retreat upstream, leaving a steep-sided gorge.

(b) (i) Human activities increase flood risk through: deforestation, which reduces interception and increases surface runoff; urbanization, which replaces soil with impermeable surfaces like concrete and tarmac; and building channel walls or bridges that restrict water flow, raising the river level upstream.
(ii) Soft engineering methods manage flooding by working with natural processes: 1. Afforestation (planting trees) increases interception and water uptake, slowing down the time it takes for water to reach the river. 2. Wetland restoration allows marshes to store excess water during peak flows. 3. River restoration returns straightened rivers to their natural meandering courses, slowing flow rates.

(c) Case study: The River Ganges, Bangladesh/India.
Opportunities: It provides nutrient-rich alluvial soil during regular flooding, which is ideal for cultivating wet rice and feeding millions of people. It provides a key transport route for moving goods and people in areas with poor road infrastructure. It also offers water for domestic use, washing, and industrial cooling.
Hazards: Severe seasonal monsoon flooding displaces millions of people, destroys homes, and drowns livestock. Waterborne disease outbreaks (like cholera) occur when sewage systems are overwhelmed by floodwaters, polluting drinking water supplies. Riverbank erosion also destroys homes and farmland situated close to the banks.

Marking scheme

(a) (i) 1 mark for correct definition: volume of water flowing in a river channel per second [1].
(ii) 2 marks (1 mark per transport method): traction [1], saltation [1], suspension [1], solution [1].
(iii) 3 marks (1 mark per change described): channel gets wider [1], deeper [1], velocity increases [1], discharge increases [1].
(iv) 4 marks (1 mark per developmental stage explained): hard rock over soft rock [1], differential erosion / soft rock eroded quicker [1], undercutting of hard rock to create overhang [1], collapse of overhang and upstream retreat leaving a gorge [1].

(b) (i) 3 marks (1 mark per human activity explained): deforestation reduces interception [1], urban concrete increases surface runoff [1], drainage channels speed up water delivery to the main channel [1].
(ii) 5 marks (1 mark per explained soft engineering method): afforestation slows lag time [1], creation of flood storage areas/wetlands [1], river restoration slows water flow [1], floodplain zoning restricts building on risky land [1].

(c) Case Study Level-of-Response Marking:
Level 1 (1-3 marks): Simple descriptions of generic opportunities (e.g., 'rivers give water and fish') and hazards (e.g., 'rivers flood and drown people'), without specific river details.
Level 2 (4-6 marks): Developed explanations of opportunities and hazards linked to a named river (e.g., 'The River Ganges floods and deposits alluvium for rice farming in Bangladesh, but monsoon floods wash away mud houses').
Level 3 (7 marks): Fully integrated and balanced response containing specific geographical names, data, and detailed explanations of both opportunities and hazards for the named river.
Question 5 · structured-essay
25 marks
Theme 3: Economic Development

Question 5
(a) (i) Define the term ecotourism. [1]
(ii) Identify two human/cultural attractions that attract tourists to a destination. [2]
(iii) Explain how the growth of international tourism can stimulate the local economy of an area. [3]
(iv) Explain why some local residents might oppose tourism development in their area. [4]

(b) (i) Describe the negative environmental impacts that can be caused by rapid tourism development. [3]
(ii) Explain how tourism can be managed to ensure it is sustainable. [5]

(c) For a named tourist area you have studied, explain the physical and human attractions that have led to the growth of tourism. [7]
Show answer & marking scheme

Worked solution

(a) (i) Ecotourism is responsible travel to natural areas that conserves the environment, sustains the well-being of the local people, and involves education.
(ii) Two human/cultural attractions: 1. Historical monuments or ancient ruins (e.g., temples, castles). 2. Traditional cultural festivals or unique local cuisine.
(iii) International tourism stimulates the local economy through the multiplier effect: tourists spend money on hotels, food, and tours, creating direct jobs. This increases the income of local workers who then spend money in other local businesses, and government tax revenues rise, which can be reinvested in local infrastructure.
(iv) Local residents might oppose tourism because: it can lead to seasonal unemployment when the tourist season ends; it causes a rise in the local cost of living and property prices, making it unaffordable for locals; it increases noise, traffic congestion, and overcrowding; and it can lead to cultural erosion or inappropriate tourist behavior that conflicts with local traditions.

(b) (i) Negative environmental impacts include: destruction of natural habitats (e.g., cutting down mangrove forests to build beach resorts); increased water and air pollution from tour buses and boats; depletion of local water resources to fill swimming pools and water golf courses; and littering/damage to coral reefs by divers.
(ii) Tourism can be made sustainable by: limiting tourist numbers using permit systems or daily quotas; employing local guides and sourcing food from local farms to keep profits in the community; building resorts using eco-friendly, locally sourced materials that blend into the environment; implementing strict waste management and recycling systems; and educating tourists about local customs and wildlife protection regulations.

(c) Case study: Mallorca, Spain.
Physical attractions: Stable, warm Mediterranean climate with over 300 days of sunshine annually, attracting sun-seekers. Stunning sandy beaches (e.g., Playa de Palma) and turquoise waters, and the rugged Sierra de Tramuntana mountain range, which provides opportunities for hiking, cycling, and scenic viewpoints.
Human attractions: Historical architecture in the capital city of Palma, including the Gothic Cathedral of Santa Maria (La Seu) and Bellver Castle. Excellent transport infrastructure, including Palma de Mallorca Airport, which makes the island highly accessible with cheap flights from Northern Europe, along with high-quality hotels, waterparks, and yacht marinas.

Marking scheme

(a) (i) 1 mark for correct definition: environmentally friendly tourism that supports locals [1].
(ii) 2 marks (1 mark per attraction): historic sites [1], museums [1], festivals [1], religious structures [1].
(iii) 3 marks (1 mark per point of economic multiplier effect explained): tourist spending creates jobs [1], local businesses supply hotels with food/goods [1], taxes collected improve local services/infrastructure [1].
(iv) 4 marks (1 mark per valid reason for opposition): noise pollution [1], rising prices of housing/goods [1], traffic jams [1], loss of cultural values/offensive dressing [1], seasonal work patterns [1].

(b) (i) 3 marks (1 mark per described environmental impact): destruction of forests/habitats [1], sewage disposal into oceans [1], drop in water table due to excessive water use [1], disruption of wildlife mating patterns [1].
(ii) 5 marks (1 mark per explained management strategy): maximum carrying capacities/caps [1], recycling schemes [1], local employment laws [1], solar power in hotels [1], eco-tax on arrivals used for conservation [1], educating tourists on fragile reefs [1].

(c) Case Study Level-of-Response Marking:
Level 1 (1-3 marks): Simple descriptions of generic physical/human attractions (e.g., 'it is hot and has nice beaches, and there are many hotels').
Level 2 (4-6 marks): Developed descriptions explaining how specific named physical and human features of a named tourist area attract visitors (e.g., 'Mallorca has the Tramuntana mountains for hiking and Palma Cathedral for historic tours, supported by the modern airport').
Level 3 (7 marks): Fully developed explanation showing clear distinction between both physical and human attractions for the named tourist destination, using specific place names and detailed geographical reasoning.
Question 6 · structured-essay
25 marks
Theme 3: Economic Development

Question 6
(a) (i) Define the term aquifer. [1]
(ii) State two domestic uses of water. [2]
(iii) Explain how agricultural activities can lead to water pollution. [3]
(iv) Describe the methods used to supply clean water to rural areas in LICs. [4]

(b) (i) Explain why the demand for water is increasing globally. [3]
(ii) Explain the potential consequences of a severe water shortage on a country's population and economy. [5]

(c) For a named area you have studied, explain how water supply is managed to meet the needs of the population and economy. [7]
Show answer & marking scheme

Worked solution

(a) (i) An aquifer is an underground layer of water-bearing, permeable rock, gravel, sand, or silt from which groundwater can be extracted.
(ii) Two domestic uses of water: 1. Drinking and cooking. 2. Washing clothes, bathing, and flushing toilets.
(iii) Agricultural activities pollute water when chemical fertilizers are washed into lakes/rivers, causing eutrophication (algal blooms that deplete oxygen and kill aquatic life); when pesticides/herbicides run off into waterways, poisoning aquatic ecosystems; and when animal manure or slurry leaks into rivers, introducing harmful bacteria.
(iv) Methods in rural LICs include: hand-dug wells to access shallow groundwater; gravity-fed schemes that pipe clean water from highland mountain springs down to villages; boreholes with mechanical or hand-pumps (like Afridev pumps) to tap deep aquifers safely; and rainwater harvesting systems that collect and store rainfall from roofs in plastic or concrete tanks.

(b) (i) Global water demand is rising because: the global human population is growing rapidly; rapid urbanization means more people live in cities with piped water connections and modern household appliances; and growing industrialization and modern agricultural irrigation require huge volumes of water to produce goods and crops.
(ii) Consequences of severe water shortages: 1. Spread of waterborne diseases as people are forced to drink dirty, contaminated water. 2. Famine and crop failures because crops cannot be irrigated, causing food insecurity. 3. Reduction in industrial output and power generation (especially in industries relying on cooling water or hydroelectric power). 4. Economic losses due to time spent by women and children walking long distances to collect water instead of working or attending school.

(c) Case study: Singapore.
Management strategies: Singapore manages water supply through the 'Four National Taps' strategy. 1. Water from local catchments: half of Singapore's land surface is designated as water catchment areas to harvest rainwater into reservoirs. 2. Imported water: importing water from Johor, Malaysia, via pipelines. 3. NEWater: high-grade reclaimed wastewater produced through advanced membrane filtration and UV disinfection, making it safe for industrial and drinking use. 4. Desalination: building high-tech reverse-osmosis desalination plants to convert seawater into fresh potable water, reducing reliance on external sources.

Marking scheme

(a) (i) 1 mark for correct definition: underground rock layer that stores water [1].
(ii) 2 marks (1 mark per domestic use): drinking [1], washing [1], cleaning [1], garden watering [1].
(iii) 3 marks (1 mark per point explained): fertilizer runoff causing eutrophication [1], pesticides poisoning aquatic life [1], animal waste/slurry contaminating water with pathogens [1].
(iv) 4 marks (1 mark per described method): hand-pumps/boreholes [1], rainwater harvesting tanks [1], gravity-fed piping [1], sand dams/wells [1].

(b) (i) 3 marks (1 mark per reason explained): population growth [1], urban migration with modern household plumbing [1], industrial growth/manufacturing [1], irrigation for farming [1].
(ii) 5 marks (1 mark per consequence explained): disease outbreaks (cholera) from dirty water [1], crop failures/famine [1], closing of factories/power stations due to lack of water [1], loss of productivity/schooling hours spent fetching water [1], conflict over shared river sources [1].

(c) Case Study Level-of-Response Marking:
Level 1 (1-3 marks): Simple descriptions of generic water supply methods (e.g., 'they built reservoirs and cleaned up water').
Level 2 (4-6 marks): Developed explanations of specific named water management policies within a named area (e.g., 'Singapore uses NEWater to recycle sewage, and desalination plants to filter seawater, along with importing water from Malaysia').
Level 3 (7 marks): Fully developed explanation of the chosen water management scheme with precise local details, accurate terminology (e.g., 'Four National Taps', 'NEWater', 'reverse osmosis'), and a balanced evaluation of how it satisfies both residential and economic needs.

Paper 22 (Skills)

Answer all questions. You must use the map extract and the insert as required.
6 Question · 60 marks
Question 1 · structured
20 marks
Study the simulated topographic map extract of the Glenvale region on a scale of 1:50,000. The contour interval is 10 metres. Grid square lines are spaced exactly 2 cm apart, representing 1 kilometre on the ground. Use this information and the Map Key to answer the following questions. Map Key: [Double red line = A302 Primary Route; Single red line = B5041 Secondary Road; Black dashed line = Footpath; Black line with cross-bars = Railway; Black circle with cross = Church with tower; Black circle with spire = Church with spire; Blue line = River; Green shading = Deciduous forest; Small blue triangle with spot height = Triangulation pillar]. (a) Identify the feature found at the following grid references: (i) The 6-figure grid reference 234762. [1 mark] (ii) The 6-figure grid reference 278794. [1 mark] (iii) The main physical feature in grid square 2275. [1 mark] (iv) The type of road in grid square 2874. [1 mark] (b) Distance and direction: (i) Measure the straight-line distance from the road bridge at 235741 to the railway station at 275771. Give your answer in metres. [2 marks] (ii) Measure the bearing of the church at 235781 from the railway station at 275771. [2 marks] (iii) State the direction of flow of the River Glen in the eastern part of the map and give one reason for your answer. [2 marks] (c) Relief and Landforms: (i) Describe the relief of the area in the north-west of the map extract (grid squares 2179, 2180, 2279 and 2280). [4 marks] (ii) Identify the physical relief feature found at 215795. [1 mark] (d) Settlement and Human Features: (i) Describe the distribution of settlement in the southern half of the map extract (south of northing 77). [4 marks] (ii) Suggest two reasons for the location of the settlement of Glenvale in grid square 2576. [2 marks]
Show answer & marking scheme

Worked solution

For (a), cross-referencing the grid coordinates with the Map Key reveals: (i) 234762 is a Church with a spire. (ii) 278794 is a Triangulation pillar. (iii) Grid square 2275 contains green shading, signifying Deciduous forest. (iv) Grid square 2874 has a double red line, which is the A302 Primary Route. For (b)(i), measuring the grid distance shows a horizontal change of 4.0 km and a vertical change of 3.0 km. Using Pythagoras, the straight-line grid distance is 5.0 km, which equals 5000 metres on a 1:50,000 scale map. For (b)(ii), measuring the angle from North at the railway station (275771) to the church (235781) gives a bearing of 284 degrees. For (b)(iii), contours crossing the river form V-shapes pointing upstream (North), indicating the river flows South. For (c)(i), relief is described by identifying high elevation points (over 400m), slope steepness via contour density, and landforms such as valleys. (c)(ii) The outward-pointing contour lines towards lower land indicate a spur. For (d)(i), settlement patterns are described as linear along transport routes, nucleated at key crossroads, and dispersed in agricultural land. (d)(ii) Glenvale is situated on flat land near water, acting as a bridging point and nodal hub for transport networks.

Marking scheme

(a)(i) 1 mark for Church with spire. (a)(ii) 1 mark for Triangulation pillar / spot height. (a)(iii) 1 mark for Deciduous forest / woodland. (a)(iv) 1 mark for Primary route / A302 / Main road. (b)(i) 2 marks for 5000m (Accept 4900m to 5100m). 1 mark for correct measurement in cm (10cm) or km (5.0km) but with incorrect or missing units. (b)(ii) 2 marks for 284 degrees (Accept 281 to 287 degrees). 1 mark if bearing is between 274 and 294 degrees. (b)(iii) 2 marks: 1 mark for direction (North to South / NNW to SSE); 1 mark for valid reason (e.g., contours shape V upstream / point North; spot heights decrease southwards; tributaries join at acute angles pointing downstream). (c)(i) Max 4 marks for any four of: High ground / height over 400m; Steep slopes in north-west (close contours); Gentler slopes in south-east (spaced contours); Valley running NW-SE; Ridge/plateau in far NW. (c)(ii) 1 mark for Spur. (d)(i) Max 4 marks for any four of: Linear along B5041 road; Nucleated at junction/crossroads in 2574; Dispersed in rural/agricultural areas; Absence/no settlement on steep slopes/forests/floodplains. (d)(ii) Max 2 marks for any two of: Gently sloping/flat land; Water supply from river/stream; Route focus / node / accessibility; Bridging point.
Question 2 · data-interpretation
8 marks
Study the climate data for Station X. Month: Jan, Feb, Mar, Apr, May, Jun, Jul, Aug, Sep, Oct, Nov, Dec. Temperature (in degrees Celsius): Jan: 26, Feb: 26.5, Mar: 27, Apr: 27, May: 27.5, Jun: 27, Jul: 26.5, Aug: 26, Sep: 26, Oct: 26.5, Nov: 27, Dec: 26.5. Rainfall (in mm): Jan: 250, Feb: 220, Mar: 180, Apr: 150, May: 80, Jun: 50, Jul: 30, Aug: 45, Sep: 90, Oct: 160, Nov: 210, Dec: 240. (a) Identify the month with the lowest rainfall and calculate the annual temperature range. [2] (b) Describe the pattern of rainfall throughout the year at Station X. [3] (c) State, with reasons, which climate type is represented by Station X. [3]
Show answer & marking scheme

Worked solution

Part (a): The month with the lowest rainfall is July (30 mm). The annual temperature range is calculated as the maximum temperature minus the minimum temperature: \(27.5^{\circ}C - 26^{\circ}C = 1.5^{\circ}C\). Part (b): Rainfall is high from October to April, with a peak in January at 250 mm. It decreases through autumn, reaching its lowest point in July (30 mm), creating a clear dry season from June to August before rising again in September. Part (c): The climate type is Tropical Savanna (or Tropical Wet-and-Dry). This is supported by: 1. A small annual temperature range of \(1.5^{\circ}C\) with high average temperatures always at or above \(26^{\circ}C\). 2. A distinct dry season in the low-sun period (June to August) where monthly rainfall drops below 60 mm. 3. High total annual precipitation with a distinct wet season during the high-sun period.

Marking scheme

Part (a) [2 marks]: 1 mark for identifying July as the driest month. 1 mark for correct calculation of temperature range: \(1.5^{\circ}C\) (must state unit). Part (b) [3 marks]: 1 mark for identifying the wet season (Oct to April / Nov to Jan). 1 mark for identifying the dry season (Jun to Aug / Jul). 1 mark for supporting with data (e.g., peak of 250 mm in Jan, minimum of 30 mm in Jul). Part (c) [3 marks]: 1 mark for identifying the climate type (Tropical Savanna / Tropical Wet-and-Dry). 2 marks for justifications (1 mark for temperature characteristics: constantly hot/low range; 1 mark for rainfall characteristics: distinct wet and dry seasons).
Question 3 · data-interpretation
8 marks
Study the demographic data for Country P and Country Q. Country P: Birth rate = 38 per 1000; Death rate = 12 per 1000; Life expectancy = 55 years; Population under 15 years old = 44%. Country Q: Birth rate = 10 per 1000; Death rate = 11 per 1000; Life expectancy = 81 years; Population under 15 years old = 15%. (a) Calculate the natural population growth rate for Country P as a percentage. Show your working. [2] (b) Compare the demographic structure of Country P with Country Q using only the data provided. [3] (c) Explain two challenges faced by Country Q's government as a result of its demographic structure. [3]
Show answer & marking scheme

Worked solution

Part (a): Rate of natural increase = Birth Rate - Death Rate = \(38 - 12 = 26\) per 1000. As a percentage: \(26 / 10 = 2.6\%\). Part (b): Country P has a much younger population structure with 44% under 15 years old, whereas Country Q has only 15% under 15 years old. Country P also has a much shorter life expectancy (55 years) than Country Q (81 years), indicating a larger elderly cohort in Country Q. Part (c): Country Q has a low birth rate and high life expectancy, indicating an aging population. Challenges include: 1. High dependency ratio with a smaller working-age population to pay taxes. 2. Increased government spending required on pensions and healthcare services for the elderly.

Marking scheme

Part (a) [2 marks]: 1 mark for correct method (Birth Rate - Death Rate). 1 mark for correct final answer: 2.6% (or 26 per 1000 if clearly calculated, but percentage is preferred). Part (b) [3 marks]: 1 mark for comparing the youth population (44% vs 15%). 1 mark for comparing life expectancy (55 years vs 81 years). 1 mark for synthesizing these into structure differences (e.g., Country P is youthful/expanding, Country Q is aging/contracting). Part (c) [3 marks]: 1 mark for identifying the issue of an aging population/low birth rate. 2 marks for explaining two distinct challenges (e.g., pension costs, healthcare demands, labor shortages, tax base reduction). Max 2 marks if no explanation is provided.
Question 4 · data-interpretation
8 marks
Study the hydrograph data for two drainage basins following a 50 mm rainstorm. Basin A (urbanized): Peak discharge = 60 cubic meters per second; Time of peak discharge = 2 hours after peak rainfall; Baseflow = 5 cubic meters per second. Basin B (forested): Peak discharge = 18 cubic meters per second; Time of peak discharge = 7 hours after peak rainfall; Baseflow = 8 cubic meters per second. (a) State the peak discharge for Basin B and calculate the difference in lag time between Basin A and Basin B. [2] (b) Describe the differences in the hydrograph shapes between the urbanized basin (Basin A) and the forested basin (Basin B). [3] (c) Explain why urbanization leads to a shorter lag time and higher peak discharge. [3]
Show answer & marking scheme

Worked solution

Part (a): Peak discharge for Basin B is 18 cubic meters per second. Lag time difference = \(7 \text{ hours} - 2 \text{ hours} = 5 \text{ hours}\). Part (b): Basin A has a much steeper rising limb, a much higher peak discharge (60 vs 18 cubic meters per second), and a shorter lag time (2 vs 7 hours). Basin B has a gentler rising and falling limb, indicating a more gradual response to rainfall. Part (c): Urbanization replaces natural vegetation and soil with impermeable surfaces (e.g., concrete, tarmac). This prevents infiltration and increases surface runoff. Additionally, artificial drainage systems (like gutters and storm drains) transport water rapidly to the river channel, reducing the lag time and increasing peak discharge.

Marking scheme

Part (a) [2 marks]: 1 mark for peak discharge of Basin B (18 m³/s / cubic meters per second). 1 mark for calculating the difference in lag time (5 hours). Part (b) [3 marks]: 1 mark for comparing the peak height (Basin A is higher/more flashy). 1 mark for comparing the steepness of limbs (Basin A is steeper/rising faster). 1 mark for comparing the lag time (Basin A is shorter/faster peak). Part (c) [3 marks]: 1 mark for mentioning impermeable surfaces/concrete. 1 mark for explaining reduced infiltration/increased overland flow (surface runoff). 1 mark for mentioning efficient artificial drainage/gutters carrying water quickly to the river.
Question 5 · data-interpretation
8 marks
Study the tourism development data for a coastal resort over a 15-year period. Year 1: Tourists = 80,000; Water consumption = 400,000 liters/day; Waste generated = 12 tonnes/day. Year 8: Tourists = 180,000; Water consumption = 950,000 liters/day; Waste generated = 35 tonnes/day. Year 15: Tourists = 320,000; Water consumption = 2,100,000 liters/day; Waste generated = 80 tonnes/day. (a) Calculate the percentage increase in tourist numbers from Year 1 to Year 15. Show your working. [2] (b) Describe the relationship between tourist numbers and water consumption over the 15-year period. Support your answer with data. [3] (c) Suggest three environmental impacts on the local marine ecosystem that could result from this level of rapid tourism growth. [3]
Show answer & marking scheme

Worked solution

Part (a): Increase in tourists = \(320,000 - 80,000 = 240,000\). Percentage increase = \((240,000 / 80,000) \times 100 = 300\%\). Part (b): There is a strong positive correlation between tourist numbers and water consumption. As tourist numbers increase, water consumption rises rapidly. From Year 1 to Year 15, while tourists multiplied by 4 (from 80k to 320k), water consumption increased more than five-fold (from 400,000 liters/day to 2,100,000 liters/day), showing that consumption per capita also increased. Part (c): Rapid tourism growth can lead to: 1. Direct physical damage to coral reefs from tourist activities (e.g., diving, boat anchors). 2. Marine pollution from untreated sewage disposal or plastic waste. 3. Destruction of coastal habitats (like mangroves) to build hotels and resorts.

Marking scheme

Part (a) [2 marks]: 1 mark for showing correct working: \(((320,000 - 80,000) / 80,000) \times 100\). 1 mark for correct final answer: 300%. Part (b) [3 marks]: 1 mark for stating the positive relationship (as tourists increase, water consumption increases). 1 mark for providing accurate data points for both variables. 1 mark for identifying that water consumption grows at a faster rate than tourist numbers (e.g., disproportionate increase). Part (c) [3 marks]: 1 mark each for three valid environmental impacts on the marine ecosystem (e.g., coral reef destruction, sewage pollution/eutrophication, loss of mangrove habitats, litter/plastic ingestion by marine life, oil spills from tourist boats). Reject general land pollution unless tied to marine impact.
Question 6 · data-interpretation
8 marks
Study the settlement and services data for three settlements in a region. Settlement X: Population = 450; Services = Primary school, General store; Sphere of influence radius = 4 km. Settlement Y: Population = 6,200; Services = Secondary school, Supermarket, Bank; Sphere of influence radius = 18 km. Settlement Z: Population = 95,000; Services = University, Specialist hospital, Department store; Sphere of influence radius = 55 km. (a) Define the term 'sphere of influence' and identify which settlement has the smallest sphere. [2] (b) Describe the relationship shown in the table between population size, the number of services, and the sphere of influence. [3] (c) Explain why a service like a specialist hospital is only found in Settlement Z and not in Settlements X or Y. [3]
Show answer & marking scheme

Worked solution

Part (a): The 'sphere of influence' is the area served by a settlement or its services. Settlement X has the smallest sphere of influence, with a radius of only 4 km. Part (b): There is a positive correlation between all three factors: as settlement population size increases, the number of services increases, and the size of the sphere of influence also increases. For example, Settlement X (pop. 450) has basic services and a 4 km sphere, whereas Settlement Z (pop. 95,000) has high-order services and a 55 km sphere. Part (c): A specialist hospital is a high-order service. It has a high threshold population, meaning it requires a large number of potential customers/patients to remain viable. Settlements X and Y do not have enough people to meet this threshold. It also has a large range, meaning patients are willing to travel long distances (up to 55 km) to access it, which aligns with Settlement Z's large sphere of influence.

Marking scheme

Part (a) [2 marks]: 1 mark for definition of sphere of influence (the area served by a settlement/shops). 1 mark for identifying Settlement X. Part (b) [3 marks]: 1 mark for stating the positive relationship between population and number of services. 1 mark for stating the positive relationship between population and sphere of influence. 1 mark for supporting with comparative data from the table (e.g., Settlement X vs Z). Part (c) [3 marks]: 1 mark for identifying that a specialist hospital is a high-order service. 1 mark for explaining threshold population (needs a large population to be profitable/viable, which only Z has). 1 mark for explaining range (people are willing to travel far for specialized services, matching Z's large sphere of influence).

Paper 42 (Coursework)

Answer all questions. Complete the tasks based on the fieldwork scenarios and data provided.
2 Question · 60 marks
Question 1 · fieldwork-analysis
30 marks
A group of students from a school in England investigated how channel characteristics change downstream along a local river, the River Swift, from near its source to its confluence. They formulated and investigated two hypotheses:

Hypothesis 1: River velocity increases downstream.
Hypothesis 2: Bed load shape becomes more rounded and average diameter decreases downstream.

Answer the following tasks based on this fieldwork scenario:

(a) Fieldwork Safety & Equipment:
(i) Explain two safety precautions the students should take when working in a river channel. [2 marks]
(ii) Identify a piece of equipment used to measure channel depth and explain how to use it safely and accurately. [2 marks]
(iii) Name an electronic instrument used to measure velocity directly. [1 mark]

(b) Data Collection:
(i) Describe how students can measure surface velocity using a float, a tape measure, and a stopwatch. [3 marks]
(ii) Suggest why measuring velocity with an electronic flow meter is more reliable and accurate than using the float method. [3 marks]

(c) Data Representation & Analysis:
The students collected data at four sites along the River Swift:
- Site A (2 km from source): Trial 1 = 0.23 m/s, Trial 2 = 0.28 m/s, Trial 3 = 0.24 m/s. Average bedload size: 14 cm.
- Site B (8 km from source): Trial 1 = 0.38 m/s, Trial 2 = 0.45 m/s, Trial 3 = 0.43 m/s. Average bedload size: 9 cm.
- Site C (15 km from source): Trial 1 = 0.55 m/s, Trial 2 = 0.61 m/s, Trial 3 = 0.58 m/s. Average bedload size: 5 cm.
- Site D (24 km from source): Trial 1 = 0.70 m/s, Trial 2 = 0.75 m/s, Trial 3 = 0.71 m/s. Average bedload size: 2 cm.

(i) Calculate the mean (average) velocity for Site B. Show your working. [2 marks]
(ii) Describe the pattern shown by the average velocity data from Site A to Site D. [2 marks]
(iii) Evaluate Hypothesis 1: 'River velocity increases downstream.' Support your conclusion with evidence from the calculated average velocities. [3 marks]
(iv) Explain why velocity typically increases downstream in a river system. [3 marks]

(d) Bed Load Analysis:
(i) Describe how students measure the shape of bed load pebbles using visual comparison charts. [2 marks]
(ii) Identify the main process of river transport or erosion that causes bed load to become smaller and smoother downstream. Explain how it works. [2 marks]
(iii) Analyze the relationship between distance from the source and average bed load size using the provided data. [2 marks]
(iv) State whether Hypothesis 2 ('Bed load shape becomes more rounded and average diameter decreases downstream') is supported. Suggest one potential source of student error when measuring bed load. [3 marks]
Show answer & marking scheme

Worked solution

(a)(i) Two safety precautions:
1. Wear sturdy footwear or waders with good grip to prevent slipping on wet rocks and protect feet from sharp objects.
2. Work in small groups/pairs to ensure help is immediately available if someone falls, and monitor river depth/speed to avoid deep or fast-moving water.

(a)(ii) Equipment: A metre rule (or a graduated ranging pole).
Usage: Place the rule vertically in the river bed so it rests lightly on the surface of the sediment (do not push it deep into mud). Turn the narrow edge of the rule parallel to the current to minimize water resistance/buildup, then read the depth at the waterline.

(a)(iii) Electronic instrument: Digital flow meter (or impeller).

(b)(i) Float method process:
1. Measure a fixed distance (e.g., 10 metres) along a straight section of the river bank using a tape measure and mark the start and end points.
2. Drop a floating object (such as an orange peel) slightly upstream of the start line. Start the stopwatch exactly as the float crosses the start line.
3. Stop the stopwatch when the float crosses the end line. Record the time. Repeat this 3 to 5 times in the same channel section and calculate the average time, then calculate velocity (\(Velocity = \text{Distance} / \text{Time}\)).

(b)(ii) Why flow meter is better:
1. Floats only measure surface velocity, which is influenced by wind resistance, whereas a flow meter measures velocity below the surface where average flow is more representative.
2. Floats can easily get caught in vegetation, rocks, or eddy currents, leading to inaccurate timings.
3. The flow meter reads velocity instantly on a digital screen, removing the human reaction-time error associated with using stopwatches.

(c)(i) Calculation for Site B:
Sum of trials = \(0.38 + 0.45 + 0.43 = 1.26\) m/s.
Mean velocity = \(1.26 / 3 = 0.42\) m/s.

(c)(ii) Pattern description: There is a steady increase in average velocity downstream from Site A to Site D. Specifically, velocity rises from \(0.25\) m/s at Site A (2 km from source) to \(0.42\) m/s at Site B (8 km), \(0.58\) m/s at Site C (15 km), and reaches a maximum of \(0.72\) m/s at Site D (24 km).

(c)(iii) Evaluation of Hypothesis 1: Hypothesis 1 is fully supported. The average velocity consistently increases from \(0.25\) m/s near the source (Site A) to \(0.72\) m/s near the mouth (Site D), with no anomalies observed.

(c)(iv) Explanation: Downstream, the volume of water (discharge) increases significantly due to tributaries joining and surface runoff. Channels become wider, deeper, and smoother, which reduces hydraulic friction against the river bed and banks (the wetted perimeter relative to cross-sectional area decreases). This reduction in friction makes the flow far more efficient, allowing the water to flow faster despite a gentler overall gradient.

(d)(i) Shape measurement: Students select pebbles randomly from the river bed at each site. They compare each pebble visually to a standardized chart, such as the Powers' Scale of Roundness, which features drawings ranging from 1 (very angular) to 6 (well-rounded), and record the corresponding score for each pebble.

(d)(ii) Process: Attrition. This occurs when rocks and pebbles carried by the river collide with each other and the river bed. This constant impact chips away sharp edges, rounding and reducing the overall size of the load over time.

(d)(iii) Analysis: There is a clear negative correlation (inverse relationship) between distance from the source and average bed load size. At 2 km from the source (Site A), the average size is \(14\) cm, which drops to \(9\) cm at 8 km (Site B), \(5\) cm at 15 km (Site C), and down to just \(2\) cm at 24 km (Site D).

(d)(iv) Conclusion & Error: Hypothesis 2 is fully supported, as the bed load becomes smaller (from \(14\) cm to \(2\) cm) and more rounded downstream. Potential student error: Selection bias, where students unconsciously select larger, smoother, or more accessible pebbles from the river bed rather than using a truly random sampling method (e.g., using a grid or quadrat).

Marking scheme

(a)(i) [2 marks total]
- 1 mark for each valid safety precaution up to 2. Accept: wading boots, group work, checking weather, staying in shallow water.

(a)(ii) [2 marks total]
- 1 mark for naming metre rule/ranging pole.
- 1 mark for describing proper/safe technique (e.g., placing perpendicular to flow, not pushing into silt).

(a)(iii) [1 mark total]
- 1 mark for flow meter / impeller.

(b)(i) [3 marks total]
- 1 mark for measuring and marking out a set distance.
- 1 mark for releasing float upstream and timing between start/end lines.
- 1 mark for repeating the process and calculating the mean.

(b)(ii) [3 marks total]
- 1 mark for noting surface friction/wind effects on floats.
- 1 mark for mentioning obstacles/vegetation trapping floats.
- 1 mark for noting digital accuracy / reduction of stopwatch reaction-time error.

(c)(i) [2 marks total]
- 1 mark for correct working: \((0.38 + 0.45 + 0.43) / 3\) or similar.
- 1 mark for correct answer: \(0.42\) m/s (must include units for full accuracy mark).

(c)(ii) [2 marks total]
- 1 mark for trend: velocity increases downstream.
- 1 mark for supporting data: citing at least two values (e.g., \(0.25\) m/s at Site A to \(0.72\) m/s at Site D).

(c)(iii) [3 marks total]
- 1 mark for stating that the hypothesis is fully supported.
- 2 marks for clear data support showing the continuous progression across all four sites (A, B, C, D) with their respective mean velocities (\(0.25, 0.42, 0.58, 0.72\) m/s).

(c)(iv) [3 marks total]
- 1 mark for mentioning increased discharge/water volume from tributaries.
- 1 mark for noting reduced friction due to wider, deeper, or smoother channels.
- 1 mark for mentioning the relative decrease in wetted perimeter compared to cross-sectional area.

(d)(i) [2 marks total]
- 1 mark for referencing Powers' Scale of Roundness or visual comparison chart.
- 1 mark for describing the matching process (comparing sample to drawings and assigning a numeric score).

(d)(ii) [2 marks total]
- 1 mark for identifying attrition.
- 1 mark for explaining that collisions between pebbles break off sharp corners/edges.

(d)(iii) [2 marks total]
- 1 mark for identifying the negative correlation / inverse relationship.
- 1 mark for using specific paired data from the table (e.g., \(14\) cm at 2 km vs \(2\) cm at 24 km).

(d)(iv) [3 marks total]
- 1 mark for stating the hypothesis is supported.
- 2 marks for explaining a source of error (e.g., subjectivity of visual classification, student selection bias when choosing pebbles).
Question 2 · fieldwork-analysis
30 marks
A group of students in the town of Oakhaven investigated urban functions, spheres of influence, and environmental quality. They formulated two hypotheses:

Hypothesis 1: High-order services have a wider sphere of influence (attract people from a greater distance) than low-order services.
Hypothesis 2: Environmental quality improves as distance from the Central Business District (CBD) increases.

Answer the following tasks based on this fieldwork scenario:

(a) Understanding Concepts:
(i) Explain the differences between a 'high-order' service and a 'low-order' service, giving one example of each. [3 marks]
(ii) Define 'sphere of influence'. [1 mark]
(iii) The students planned to interview 50 shoppers using a systematic sampling method. Explain how they would carry out systematic sampling and state one advantage of this method. [2 marks]

(b) Questionnaire and Environmental Quality Surveys (EQS):
(i) Write three questions that the students could include in a questionnaire to find out where people have travelled from and why they are visiting the town center. [3 marks]
(ii) To investigate Hypothesis 2, students conducted an Environmental Quality Survey (EQS). Suggest three distinct criteria (environmental indicators) they could score at each site. [3 marks]
(iii) Briefly explain how an EQS is scored and how the final total score is calculated. [1 mark]

(c) Analysis of Results:
The students collected questionnaire data from 50 respondents for two services in Oakhaven:
- Service X (Department Store - High-order)
- Service Y (Local Convenience Store - Low-order)

The distance travelled by respondents is summarized below:
- Service X: Mean distance = 14.5 km, Maximum distance = 35.0 km
- Service Y: Mean distance = 1.2 km, Maximum distance = 3.0 km

(i) Evaluate Hypothesis 1: 'High-order services have a wider sphere of influence than low-order services.' Support your decision with specific figures from the questionnaire results. [3 marks]
(ii) The students conducted EQS at 5 different sites at varying distances from the CBD. The total EQS scores (from a range of -10 to +10) were:
- Site 1 (0.5 km from CBD): -6
- Site 2 (1.5 km from CBD): -2
- Site 3 (3.0 km from CBD): +4
- Site 4 (4.5 km from CBD): +8
- Site 5 (6.0 km from CBD): +11 (Score exceeded scale due to exceptional green space)

Describe the relationship shown between distance from the CBD and environmental quality score. Use data to support your answer. [3 marks]
(iii) Suggest two geographical reasons why environmental quality is lower closer to the CBD. [2 marks]
(iv) Draw a conclusion for Hypothesis 2: 'Environmental quality improves as distance from the CBD increases.' Explain your reasoning. [3 marks]

(d) Fieldwork Evaluation:
(i) Suggest two limitations of using questionnaires to determine a service's sphere of influence. [2 marks]
(ii) Explain how the students could improve the overall reliability and accuracy of their urban environmental quality study if they were to repeat it. [4 marks]
Show answer & marking scheme

Worked solution

(a)(i) High-order services are specialized services that sell expensive goods, are visited infrequently, have a large threshold population (minimum number of people needed to support them), and a large range (e.g., department stores, jewelers, or specialized hospitals). Low-order services are basic, everyday services that sell inexpensive goods, are visited frequently, have a small threshold population, and a small range (e.g., newsagents, bakeries, or convenience stores).

(a)(ii) Sphere of Influence: The geographic area served by a settlement, shop, or service, representing the area from which customers are attracted.

(a)(iii) Systematic Sampling: The students would stand at a fixed point and select people passing by at a regular interval, such as every 5th or 10th person. Advantage: It is quick and easy to implement, eliminates personal bias in selecting interviewees, and ensures a more even distribution of respondents across the survey period.

(b)(i) Three questionnaire questions:
1. What is your home postcode or the name of the town/village you travelled from today?
2. What is your primary reason for visiting Oakhaven town centre today?
3. Which mode of transport did you use to travel here today?

(b)(ii) Three EQS criteria:
1. Amount of litter, debris, and rubbish on the streets.
2. Volume of traffic noise and general acoustic environment.
3. Air quality, level of exhaust fumes, and smells.
(Other acceptable answers: condition of building facades, presence of green spaces/trees, pedestrian safety/pavement quality).

(b)(iii) EQS scoring: Each criterion is given a score on a scale (e.g., from -2 representing very poor to +2 representing excellent). The scores for all selected criteria at a site are added together to produce a single final environmental quality index/score.

(c)(i) Evaluation of Hypothesis 1: The hypothesis is fully supported. Customers travel significantly further to visit the high-order Service X (department store) than the low-order Service Y (convenience store). The mean travel distance for Service X is \(14.5\) km (with a maximum of \(35.0\) km) compared to a mean travel distance of only \(1.2\) km (with a maximum of \(3.0\) km) for Service Y.

(c)(ii) Relationship description: There is a strong positive correlation between distance from the CBD and the environmental quality score. As distance from the CBD increases, the environmental quality improves. For example, at \(0.5\) km from the CBD, the score is highly negative at \(-6\), but it becomes positive at \(3.0\) km with a score of \(+4\), and reaches its highest score of \(+11\) at \(6.0\) km.

(c)(iii) Two reasons for lower environmental quality near CBD:
1. Concentrated road traffic and congestion in the center lead to elevated noise levels and air pollution from vehicle exhausts.
2. High density of buildings and intensive commercial use leave very little land available for green open spaces, parks, or street-level planting.

(c)(iv) Conclusion for Hypothesis 2: Hypothesis 2 is fully supported. The EQS data shows a continuous, uninterrupted upward trend in environmental quality from \(-6\) (at \(0.5\) km) to \(+11\) (at \(6.0\) km) as one moves away from the urban center.

(d)(i) Questionnaire limitations:
1. People may not be able to estimate their exact travel distances accurately, leading to unreliable data.
2. Refusals to participate or language/age barriers can lead to a non-representative sample of visitors.

(d)(ii) EQS improvements:
1. Repeat the EQS assessments at multiple different times of the day (e.g., morning rush hour, midday, and evening) and on different days (weekdays vs. weekends) to calculate a representative average.
2. Have multiple students/groups rate each site independently and average their results to minimize individual subjectivity.
3. Increase the number of survey sites (e.g., assessing 10 or 15 points instead of 5) to produce a denser and more comprehensive spatial pattern.
4. Incorporate objective digital tools, such as decibel meter apps to measure traffic noise levels and PM2.5 sensors to measure actual air pollution, rather than relying solely on visual/auditory estimation.

Marking scheme

(a)(i) [3 marks total]
- 1 mark for describing high-order services (large range, large threshold population, expensive/infrequent purchase).
- 1 mark for describing low-order services (small range, small threshold, cheap/frequent purchase).
- 1 mark for providing correct, contrasting examples (e.g., department store vs convenience store).

(a)(ii) [1 mark total]
- 1 mark for defining sphere of influence as the market catchment area of a service or settlement.

(a)(iii) [2 marks total]
- 1 mark for describing the mechanism of systematic sampling (e.g., choosing every n-th person).
- 1 mark for stating a valid advantage (e.g., reduces bias, easy to execute).

(b)(i) [3 marks total]
- 1 mark for each of the three clear, logical questions related to travel origin, purpose, or transport mode.

(b)(ii) [3 marks total]
- 1 mark for each of the three distinct environmental criteria suggested (e.g., litter, traffic noise, air pollution, building quality, greenery).

(b)(iii) [1 mark total]
- 1 mark for explaining that a numerical scale is applied to each category and the individual scores are summed.

(c)(i) [3 marks total]
- 1 mark for stating that the hypothesis is fully supported.
- 2 marks for using contrasting paired data from both Service X and Service Y (e.g., mean of \(14.5\) km vs \(1.2\) km, or max of \(35\) km vs \(3\) km).

(c)(ii) [3 marks total]
- 1 mark for identifying the positive relationship (as distance increases, score increases).
- 2 marks for supporting this with specific data points (e.g., \(-6\) at \(0.5\) km, transitioning to positive \(+4\) at \(3.0\) km, and peaking at \(+11\) at \(6.0\) km).

(c)(iii) [2 marks total]
- 1 mark per valid explanation up to 2 (e.g., heavy traffic congestion causing air/noise pollution, lack of green parks, older dilapidated building stock in old urban cores).

(c)(iv) [3 marks total]
- 1 mark for confirming hypothesis support.
- 2 marks for explaining the trend using the complete sequence of data points showing steady, positive gains without any anomalies.

(d)(i) [2 marks total]
- 1 mark per valid limitation up to 2 (e.g., guest inaccuracy in distance reporting, shopper refusal/non-response, small sample size, snapshot-only representation).

(d)(ii) [4 marks total]
- 1 mark per well-explained improvement up to 4. Accept: taking measurements at multiple times of day, averaging scores from multiple observer groups, increasing the total number of survey sites, using objective/instrumental measurements instead of subjective sensory ratings.

Wondering how well you actually know this?

Thinka is an AI practice app for DSE students — unlimited questions, instant auto-marking, and detailed step-by-step solutions. 100,000+ students use it to confirm they actually know it, not just think they do.

Want more questions like this? Practice unlimited on Thinka — instant answers included.

Start Practising Free