Question 1 · Structured Question
20 marksRefer to Fig. 1 (below) which outlines the development strategy of the Alpine Eco-Valley Board (AEVB), a National Tourism Organisation (NTO).
Fig. 1: Alpine Eco-Valley Board (AEVB) Strategy
The AEVB is the National Tourism Organisation (NTO) responsible for promoting and managing sustainable tourism in the high-altitude region of Eco-Valley. Due to a recent surge in popularity among winter sports enthusiasts and summer hikers, local ecosystems have come under pressure. The AEVB's new strategy focuses on dispersing visitors to lesser-known villages and promoting off-peak travel, while collaborating with local businesses to maintain authentic cultural experiences.
(a) Identify four functions of a National Tourism Organisation (NTO), such as the AEVB. [4]
(b) Explain two negative environmental impacts that can result from rapid tourism growth in fragile alpine destinations. [4]
(c) Explain three ways the AEVB can manage negative sociocultural impacts in the valley. [6]
(d) Analyse how the key tourism characteristic of perishability affects how local accommodation providers in the Alpine Eco-Valley must manage and market their services. [6]
Fig. 1: Alpine Eco-Valley Board (AEVB) Strategy
The AEVB is the National Tourism Organisation (NTO) responsible for promoting and managing sustainable tourism in the high-altitude region of Eco-Valley. Due to a recent surge in popularity among winter sports enthusiasts and summer hikers, local ecosystems have come under pressure. The AEVB's new strategy focuses on dispersing visitors to lesser-known villages and promoting off-peak travel, while collaborating with local businesses to maintain authentic cultural experiences.
(a) Identify four functions of a National Tourism Organisation (NTO), such as the AEVB. [4]
(b) Explain two negative environmental impacts that can result from rapid tourism growth in fragile alpine destinations. [4]
(c) Explain three ways the AEVB can manage negative sociocultural impacts in the valley. [6]
(d) Analyse how the key tourism characteristic of perishability affects how local accommodation providers in the Alpine Eco-Valley must manage and market their services. [6]
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
(a)
1. Marketing and international/domestic promotion of the destination.
2. Conducting tourism research, market analysis, and collecting visitor statistics.
3. Setting quality standards, regulations, and grading systems for tourism providers.
4. Developing new tourism products, packages, and coordinating destination management planning.
(b)
1. Soil erosion and damage to alpine flora: High volumes of hikers leaving designated paths trample fragile alpine vegetation, causing soil compaction and severe erosion.
2. Water and land pollution: Rapid increases in visitor numbers produce higher amounts of solid waste and sewage, which can overload local wastewater facilities and contaminate pristine mountain streams.
(c)
1. Community consultation and involvement: Holding regular forums with local residents to involve them in the planning process, ensuring their concerns are addressed and reducing host-visitor resentment.
2. Carrying capacity limits: Implementing quotas or capping the daily number of visitors allowed on sensitive hiking trails and alpine villages to prevent overcrowding and preserve local peace.
3. Visitor education and codes of conduct: Publishing and distributing guidelines on local customs, responsible behaviour, and cultural respect at key entry points and via digital apps to reduce inappropriate tourist behaviour.
(d)
Perishability means that accommodation bed-nights cannot be stored for sale at a later date; if a hotel room is unsold tonight, that revenue is lost forever. In the Alpine Eco-Valley, where tourism is highly seasonal (peaks in winter/summer), providers must manage this by:
- Employing dynamic, seasonal pricing strategies (lowering prices during shoulder and off-peak seasons to stimulate demand and avoid empty rooms).
- Creating multi-day packages or bundles (e.g., combining accommodation with ski passes or guided hikes) to secure bookings well in advance.
- Using last-minute distribution channels and online travel agents (OTAs) to sell remaining inventory at short notice, sacrificing yield to maintain high occupancy rates and cover fixed costs.
1. Marketing and international/domestic promotion of the destination.
2. Conducting tourism research, market analysis, and collecting visitor statistics.
3. Setting quality standards, regulations, and grading systems for tourism providers.
4. Developing new tourism products, packages, and coordinating destination management planning.
(b)
1. Soil erosion and damage to alpine flora: High volumes of hikers leaving designated paths trample fragile alpine vegetation, causing soil compaction and severe erosion.
2. Water and land pollution: Rapid increases in visitor numbers produce higher amounts of solid waste and sewage, which can overload local wastewater facilities and contaminate pristine mountain streams.
(c)
1. Community consultation and involvement: Holding regular forums with local residents to involve them in the planning process, ensuring their concerns are addressed and reducing host-visitor resentment.
2. Carrying capacity limits: Implementing quotas or capping the daily number of visitors allowed on sensitive hiking trails and alpine villages to prevent overcrowding and preserve local peace.
3. Visitor education and codes of conduct: Publishing and distributing guidelines on local customs, responsible behaviour, and cultural respect at key entry points and via digital apps to reduce inappropriate tourist behaviour.
(d)
Perishability means that accommodation bed-nights cannot be stored for sale at a later date; if a hotel room is unsold tonight, that revenue is lost forever. In the Alpine Eco-Valley, where tourism is highly seasonal (peaks in winter/summer), providers must manage this by:
- Employing dynamic, seasonal pricing strategies (lowering prices during shoulder and off-peak seasons to stimulate demand and avoid empty rooms).
- Creating multi-day packages or bundles (e.g., combining accommodation with ski passes or guided hikes) to secure bookings well in advance.
- Using last-minute distribution channels and online travel agents (OTAs) to sell remaining inventory at short notice, sacrificing yield to maintain high occupancy rates and cover fixed costs.
Marking scheme
(a) Award 1 mark for each of four correctly identified NTO functions.
Acceptable answers include: Destination marketing/promotion, research and statistical analysis, establishing regulations/grading schemes, tourism product development, coordinating public-private partnerships, providing tourist information services.
(b) Award 1 mark for identifying a valid negative environmental impact, plus 1 mark for explanation in context (up to 2 impacts).
- Soil erosion / vegetation trampling (1) caused by hikers straying from marked paths, leading to long-term damage to fragile alpine flora (1).
- Water pollution / littering (1) due to overcrowding overloading the valley's waste disposal systems, leading to waste entering freshwater rivers (1).
(c) Award 1 mark for identifying a valid sociocultural management method, plus 1 mark for explanation/application (up to 3 methods).
- Resident involvement/consultation (1) which gives locals a voice in tourism development and minimises the risk of host-guest conflicts (1).
- Carrying capacity limits / visitor caps (1) which prevents physical overcrowding in traditional villages and preserves the local way of life (1).
- Cultural codes of conduct (1) which educate tourists on local traditions, reducing disrespectful behaviour (1).
(d) Use Level of Response marking:
- Level 1 (1-2 marks): Identifies/defines perishability and/or basic marketing responses (e.g., unsold rooms are lost revenue; hotels lower prices in low season).
- Level 2 (3-4 marks): Explains how perishability affects the Alpine Eco-Valley providers (e.g., seasonal demand fluctuations mean they must balance peak high prices with low-season discounts to maintain cash flow).
- Level 3 (5-6 marks): Analytically evaluates the effectiveness of strategies used by providers to combat perishability (e.g., discusses the balance between dynamic pricing and brand value, showing that over-reliance on last-minute discounts may harm the luxury image of the destination but is necessary to mitigate perishability).
Acceptable answers include: Destination marketing/promotion, research and statistical analysis, establishing regulations/grading schemes, tourism product development, coordinating public-private partnerships, providing tourist information services.
(b) Award 1 mark for identifying a valid negative environmental impact, plus 1 mark for explanation in context (up to 2 impacts).
- Soil erosion / vegetation trampling (1) caused by hikers straying from marked paths, leading to long-term damage to fragile alpine flora (1).
- Water pollution / littering (1) due to overcrowding overloading the valley's waste disposal systems, leading to waste entering freshwater rivers (1).
(c) Award 1 mark for identifying a valid sociocultural management method, plus 1 mark for explanation/application (up to 3 methods).
- Resident involvement/consultation (1) which gives locals a voice in tourism development and minimises the risk of host-guest conflicts (1).
- Carrying capacity limits / visitor caps (1) which prevents physical overcrowding in traditional villages and preserves the local way of life (1).
- Cultural codes of conduct (1) which educate tourists on local traditions, reducing disrespectful behaviour (1).
(d) Use Level of Response marking:
- Level 1 (1-2 marks): Identifies/defines perishability and/or basic marketing responses (e.g., unsold rooms are lost revenue; hotels lower prices in low season).
- Level 2 (3-4 marks): Explains how perishability affects the Alpine Eco-Valley providers (e.g., seasonal demand fluctuations mean they must balance peak high prices with low-season discounts to maintain cash flow).
- Level 3 (5-6 marks): Analytically evaluates the effectiveness of strategies used by providers to combat perishability (e.g., discusses the balance between dynamic pricing and brand value, showing that over-reliance on last-minute discounts may harm the luxury image of the destination but is necessary to mitigate perishability).