Question 1 · Short Answer Question
9 marksExplain how one hormone influences human behaviour, with reference to one study.
Show answer & marking schemeHide answer & marking scheme
Worked solution
Oxytocin is a hormone produced in the hypothalamus and released into the bloodstream by the pituitary gland. It acts both as a hormone in the body and as a neurotransmitter in the brain, and it plays a vital role in human social behaviours such as trust, empathy, and social bonding. Trust is essential for cooperative human relationships, but it carries a risk of betrayal. Oxytocin is believed to facilitate trust by downregulating the activation of the amygdala, the brain area responsible for processing fear and threat detection, thereby reducing the psychological fear of betrayal.
A key study investigating this effect is Baumgartner et al. (2008). The aim of the study was to investigate the role of oxytocin after trust had been broken in a social game. Participants played a 'trust game' in which they acted as investors. They had to decide whether to keep money or share it with a trustee. If they shared it, the money was tripled, and the trustee then decided whether to share the profits (cooperate) or keep all the money (betrayal). Participants received either an oxytocin nasal spray or a placebo.
Using fMRI scans, researchers monitored the participants' brain activity. During the game, participants were given feedback that their trust had been breached in 50% of the trials. The results showed that participants in the placebo group became much less trusting and reduced their investments after learning of the betrayal. In contrast, participants who received oxytocin continued to invest at similar rates, maintaining high levels of trust even after being betrayed. The fMRI scans revealed that the oxytocin group had decreased activation in both the amygdala and the caudate nucleus (which is associated with learning and memory of trust-related decisions).
This study demonstrates how oxytocin influences human behaviour. By reducing activity in the amygdala, the hormone dampens the emotional processing of fear and the threat of betrayal. This biological mechanism allows individuals to maintain trust and continue social cooperation despite receiving negative feedback or experiencing betrayal.
A key study investigating this effect is Baumgartner et al. (2008). The aim of the study was to investigate the role of oxytocin after trust had been broken in a social game. Participants played a 'trust game' in which they acted as investors. They had to decide whether to keep money or share it with a trustee. If they shared it, the money was tripled, and the trustee then decided whether to share the profits (cooperate) or keep all the money (betrayal). Participants received either an oxytocin nasal spray or a placebo.
Using fMRI scans, researchers monitored the participants' brain activity. During the game, participants were given feedback that their trust had been breached in 50% of the trials. The results showed that participants in the placebo group became much less trusting and reduced their investments after learning of the betrayal. In contrast, participants who received oxytocin continued to invest at similar rates, maintaining high levels of trust even after being betrayed. The fMRI scans revealed that the oxytocin group had decreased activation in both the amygdala and the caudate nucleus (which is associated with learning and memory of trust-related decisions).
This study demonstrates how oxytocin influences human behaviour. By reducing activity in the amygdala, the hormone dampens the emotional processing of fear and the threat of betrayal. This biological mechanism allows individuals to maintain trust and continue social cooperation despite receiving negative feedback or experiencing betrayal.
Marking scheme
Marks are awarded out of 9, using the official IB Psychology Short Answer Question (SAQ) rubric:
- **1 to 3 marks**: The response is relevant to the question but is descriptive rather than explanatory. Knowledge of the hormone or the behaviour is limited or lacks accuracy. The study is mentioned but not clearly described or linked to the hormone's influence.
- **4 to 6 marks**: The response is clear and focused. It identifies a specific hormone and describes its influence on human behaviour. A relevant study is described, but the integration or explanation of how the study supports the biological mechanism is incomplete or lacks depth. Psychological terminology is used but may not be fully precise.
- **7 to 9 marks**: The response is well-structured, highly accurate, and focused. It clearly explains how the specified hormone influences human behaviour by explaining the underlying biological process. A highly relevant study is described accurately (including aims, methods, results, and conclusion) and is seamlessly integrated to support the explanation. Precise psychological and biological terminology is used consistently throughout.
- **1 to 3 marks**: The response is relevant to the question but is descriptive rather than explanatory. Knowledge of the hormone or the behaviour is limited or lacks accuracy. The study is mentioned but not clearly described or linked to the hormone's influence.
- **4 to 6 marks**: The response is clear and focused. It identifies a specific hormone and describes its influence on human behaviour. A relevant study is described, but the integration or explanation of how the study supports the biological mechanism is incomplete or lacks depth. Psychological terminology is used but may not be fully precise.
- **7 to 9 marks**: The response is well-structured, highly accurate, and focused. It clearly explains how the specified hormone influences human behaviour by explaining the underlying biological process. A highly relevant study is described accurately (including aims, methods, results, and conclusion) and is seamlessly integrated to support the explanation. Precise psychological and biological terminology is used consistently throughout.