解题
(a) Level of response guidance (indicative content, to be marked using the 4-band rubric below): The semi-conservative model - during DNA replication, the enzyme DNA helicase moves along the DNA molecule, unwinding the double helix and breaking the hydrogen bonds holding the two complementary polynucleotide strands together, separating them into two single strands. Each of these original (parental) strands then acts as a template: free DNA nucleotides in the surrounding nucleoplasm are attracted to, and pair with, the exposed bases on each template strand by specific complementary base pairing (A with T, C with G). The enzyme DNA polymerase then catalyses a condensation reaction, joining adjacent nucleotides together to form a new, continuous sugar-phosphate backbone along each template strand. The result of this process is two new DNA double helix molecules, each one made up of one original (parental) strand and one newly synthesised strand; because half of each new molecule is 'conserved' from the original molecule, this model of replication is called semi-conservative. Meselson and Stahl's experiment - in 1958, Meselson and Stahl designed an experiment to distinguish between three competing theories of DNA replication that existed at the time: the conservative model (which proposed the original double helix stayed completely intact, with an entirely separate, entirely new molecule made alongside it), the dispersive model (which proposed that both strands of both resulting molecules would contain a scattered mixture of original and new DNA segments), and the semi-conservative model. They grew E. coli bacteria for many generations in a growth medium containing only the heavy nitrogen isotope, 15N, so that all of the nitrogen atoms within the bases of the bacterial DNA (all newly incorporated during this time) became heavy, making this DNA denser than normal DNA. They then transferred these bacteria into a growth medium containing only the normal, lighter nitrogen isotope, 14N, and allowed the bacteria to replicate their DNA for one, and then a second, generation, extracting a DNA sample after each generation. Each DNA sample was separated by density using density-gradient centrifugation, a technique that separates molecules into distinct bands according to their mass. After one generation of replication in the 14N medium, all of the DNA formed a single band at a density exactly intermediate between fully heavy (15N/15N) DNA and fully light (14N/14N) DNA; this result immediately ruled out the conservative model, since that model predicted two separate bands after one generation (one fully heavy, unreplicated original DNA, and one fully light, entirely new DNA), rather than the single intermediate band that was actually observed. After a second generation of replication in the 14N medium, two distinct bands appeared: one still at the intermediate density (as seen after generation one), and a second, new band at the fully light density. This result is exactly what the semi-conservative model predicts, since each intermediate (hybrid) molecule from the first generation contains one heavy strand and one light strand; when this hybrid molecule itself replicates, each of its two strands (one heavy, one light) acts as a separate template for a new light strand, producing one hybrid (intermediate) molecule and one fully light molecule from each original hybrid molecule, giving the observed mixture of intermediate and fully light bands. This result also ruled out the dispersive model, since that model predicts that, however many generations of replication occur, all of the resulting DNA molecules would still contain some scattered heavy DNA mixed throughout every molecule, and so would all still appear as a single band, of a density that gradually becomes lighter with each generation, rather than splitting into two clearly separate bands (one intermediate, one fully light) as was actually observed. Final answer: DNA replication is semi-conservative, with each new DNA molecule containing one original (template) strand and one newly synthesised strand, produced via helicase unwinding the double helix and DNA polymerase joining new complementary nucleotides to each template strand; Meselson and Stahl's density-gradient centrifugation results (a single intermediate band after one generation, then both an intermediate and a fully light band after a second generation) matched the predictions of the semi-conservative model and ruled out both the conservative and dispersive models. (b) Meiosis produces genetically different gametes through two main features. Independent segregation (assortment) of homologous chromosomes occurs during meiosis I: each pair of homologous chromosomes lines up at the equator of the cell and separates independently of every other pair, meaning that the particular combination of maternal and paternal chromosomes ending up in each resulting gamete is random and differs between different gametes produced by the same individual, generating many different possible chromosome combinations. Crossing over (genetic recombination) occurs during prophase I, when homologous chromosomes pair up closely together (forming a bivalent) and exchange corresponding sections of DNA between non-sister chromatids at points of contact called chiasmata; this creates new combinations of alleles along a chromosome that were not present on either original parental chromosome, further increasing genetic variation among the gametes produced. (c) Meiosis produces haploid cells (gametes), each containing only one copy of each chromosome (half the normal diploid chromosome number of the parent cell). This is important for sexual reproduction because, at fertilisation, two haploid gametes (one from each parent) fuse together to form a diploid zygote, restoring the full, normal diploid chromosome number (one complete set inherited from each parent); if gametes were not haploid (i.e. if meiosis did not halve the chromosome number before fertilisation), the chromosome number would double with every generation, which would not be sustainable.
评分标准
(a) Level of response mark scheme (9 marks, 4 bands). Excellent (7-9 marks): accurately describes the semi-conservative mechanism (helicase unwinding/breaking hydrogen bonds, template strands, complementary base pairing of new nucleotides, DNA polymerase joining nucleotides, resulting hybrid molecules) AND accurately describes the Meselson-Stahl experimental method (15N/14N labelling, density-gradient centrifugation) and correctly explains how BOTH the generation-1 result (single intermediate band, ruling out conservative) and the generation-2 result (intermediate + fully light bands, ruling out dispersive) support the semi-conservative model; accurate specialist vocabulary throughout; clear, coherent, well-structured writing. Good (4-6 marks): describes the semi-conservative mechanism with reasonable accuracy and gives a generally correct account of the Meselson-Stahl experiment and at least one of the two key results, though may be less complete or less precise in linking results to ruling out the alternative models; mostly accurate vocabulary; generally clear writing with minor errors. Basic (1-3 marks): gives a limited or partially correct description of DNA replication and/or the Meselson-Stahl experiment, with little development or explanation of how the results distinguish between the models; writing may be list-like or contain errors that hinder meaning. 0 marks: no creditable response. (b) [1] mark for each correctly described feature, to a maximum of 3: independent segregation/assortment of homologous chromosomes [1-2 depending on detail]; crossing over/recombination between non-sister chromatids at chiasmata [1-2 depending on detail] (award up to 3 marks total across both features, with at least one mark requiring correct linkage to increased genetic variation). (c) [1] correctly states haploid; [1] correctly explains that fusion of two haploid gametes at fertilisation restores the diploid number, preventing it doubling each generation. Maximum 14 marks.