An original Thinka practice paper modelled on the structure and difficulty of the Jun 2025 CCEA GCSE Government and Politics 4830 paper. Not affiliated with or reproduced from CCEA.
Unit 1: 甲部
Answer all questions. Write short answers, complete definitions, and fill matching tables.
14 题目 · 24 分
题目 1 · Single-mark Recall
1 分
Name the electoral system used to elect Members of Parliament (MPs) at Westminster.
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
MPs are elected to the UK Parliament using the First Past the Post system, where the candidate with the most votes in a single-member constituency wins.
评分标准
[1] First Past the Post / FPTP. Reject 'Single Transferable Vote' (used for the NI Assembly, not Westminster).
题目 2 · Single-mark Recall
1 分
Give one option available to increase political participation through voting.
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
Options to increase participation through voting include lowering the voting age to 16 and introducing compulsory voting.
评分标准
[1] Lowering the voting age / compulsory voting.
题目 3 · Single-mark Recall
1 分
Name the type of vote that allows citizens to decide directly on a single issue, rather than electing a representative.
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
A referendum is a direct vote in which the electorate decides a specific question or issue, such as EU membership, rather than electing a representative.
评分标准
[1] Referendum.
题目 4 · Single-mark Recall
1 分
Give one age group that typically has a lower voter turnout than the national average.
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
Turnout among young people (typically 18-24 year olds) is consistently lower than the national average in UK and NI elections.
评分标准
[1] Young people / 18-24 year olds (or similar young-age band).
题目 5 · Single-mark Recall
1 分
Name one layer of government in Northern Ireland below the Northern Ireland Assembly.
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
Below the Northern Ireland Assembly, local councils form another layer of elected government, responsible for local services.
评分标准
[1] Local council.
题目 6 · Single-mark Recall
1 分
Give one key feature of a democracy.
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
Key features of a democracy include free and fair elections, protection of rights, separation of powers, and freedom of the press.
评分标准
[1] Any one of: free and fair elections; protection of rights; separation of powers; freedom of the press.
题目 7 · Single-mark Recall
1 分
Name one issue on which left-wing and right-wing parties traditionally hold different views.
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
Left-wing and right-wing parties traditionally differ on the economy, education, the environment and immigration.
评分标准
[1] Any one of: the economy; education; the environment; immigration.
题目 8 · Single-mark Recall
1 分
Name one type of media used in contemporary society to communicate political information.
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
Political information is communicated through television, print, e-media, radio and social media.
评分标准
[1] Any one valid media form.
题目 9 · Single-mark Recall
1 分
Name one type of pressure group.
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
Pressure groups can be classified as cause groups, sectional groups, insider groups or outsider groups.
评分标准
[1] Any one of: cause group; sectional group; insider group; outsider group.
题目 10 · Two-mark Definition/Advantage
2 分
Give one advantage of the Single Transferable Vote (STV) system used to elect MLAs.
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
STV is a form of proportional representation: because voters rank candidates and surplus/eliminated votes are transferred, the final allocation of seats more closely matches the share of first-preference votes each party won than under First Past the Post, giving smaller parties a fairer chance of representation.
评分标准
[1] Basic identification of an advantage, e.g. more proportional/fairer to smaller parties; [1] development/explanation of why. Any other valid advantage (e.g. voters can rank multiple candidates, reducing 'wasted' votes) [2].
题目 11 · Two-mark Definition/Advantage
2 分
What is meant by the term 'freedom of the press'?
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
Freedom of the press means that journalists and media organisations can investigate, report and comment on matters of public interest - including criticising the government and those in power - without being censored or unduly controlled by the state.
评分标准
[1] Basic idea that media can report/criticise without state control; [1] development, e.g. reference to holding power to account. Any other valid point [2].
题目 12 · Two-mark Definition/Advantage
2 分
Give one advantage of joining a pressure group, rather than a political party, to achieve a political aim.
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
Pressure groups typically campaign on one specific issue or cause, so a member does not need to agree with a whole manifesto of policies as they would to join a political party; this can also make it quicker and easier to see a direct campaigning result on that one issue.
评分标准
[1] Basic identification of an advantage, e.g. can focus on a single issue/no need to agree with a full manifesto; [1] development. Any other valid point (e.g. often easier/quicker to join, less formal commitment) [2].
题目 13 · Matching Grid
4 分
Match the correct term from the list below to its description in the grid. Write the correct term next to each number.
1. A political viewpoint that generally favours greater government intervention in the economy and redistribution of wealth. 2. A document published by a political party before an election, setting out the policies it will pursue if elected. 3. A voter who does not consistently support the same political party from one election to the next. 4. A political viewpoint that generally favours free markets, lower taxation and limited government intervention.
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
1 = Left-wing (favours state intervention/redistribution); 2 = Manifesto (a party's pre-election policy document); 3 = Floating voter (switches party allegiance between elections); 4 = Right-wing (favours free markets/low tax/limited government).
评分标准
[1] mark for each correct match: 1-Left-wing [1]; 2-Manifesto [1]; 3-Floating voter [1]; 4-Right-wing [1]. Maximum [4].
题目 14 · For/Against Binary Classification
5 分
Read the statements below. Tick (✔) the correct box to show if the arguments are For or Against lowering the voting age to 16 in Northern Ireland.
Statement For Against 1. Sixteen-year-olds can work, pay taxes and join the armed forces, so they should be able to vote on decisions that affect them. 2. Sixteen-year-olds may lack the life experience and political knowledge needed to make an informed voting choice. 3. Involving young people earlier could build a lifelong habit of voting and increase long-term turnout. 4. Extending the vote to 16-year-olds could dilute the influence of older, more consistent voters. 5. Political education in schools means many 16-year-olds are already well informed about current affairs.
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
Statements 1, 3 and 5 support extending the vote to 16-year-olds (responsibility/rights already held, building lifelong voting habits, political education), so are 'For'. Statements 2 and 4 give reasons to keep the voting age at 18 (lack of experience, diluting other voters' influence), so are 'Against'.
评分标准
[1] mark for each correctly ticked statement: 1-For [1]; 2-Against [1]; 3-For [1]; 4-Against [1]; 5-For [1]. Maximum [5].
Answer all questions using the provided source material and your own knowledge.
4 题目 · 25 分
题目 1 · Source-Prompted Description
5 分
Source A 'In one country, citizens vote in regular elections to choose their government, courts operate independently of ministers, and journalists are free to criticise politicians without fear of arrest. In a neighbouring country, one leader has remained in power for over twenty years, opposition parties are banned, and newspapers that criticise the government are shut down.'
Using Source A and your own knowledge, describe some of the key features that distinguish a democracy from a dictatorship.
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
Indicative content: from Source A - regular elections and an independent judiciary (separation of powers) as features of democracy; a free press able to criticise government without punishment; by contrast, one-person/one-party rule with no free elections, banned opposition parties, and suppression of critical media as features of dictatorship. From own knowledge - democracies protect citizens' rights (e.g. freedom of speech and assembly), while dictatorships often use coercion to silence opposition; democracies have accountable government (leaders can be removed by voters), while dictatorial rule persists without a genuine electoral check.
评分标准
Level 1 (1-2 marks): Basic, undeveloped description with limited/no use of the source. Level 2 (3-4 marks): Sound description drawing on the source OR own knowledge. Level 3 (5 marks): Detailed, well-developed description drawing on both Source A and own knowledge. An answer that fails to refer to the Source can be awarded a maximum of Level 2 (4 marks).
题目 2 · Short Structured Explanation
6 分
Explain some of the ways in which MLAs represent the interests of their constituents in the Northern Ireland Assembly.
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
Indicative content: geographical representation - MLAs are elected to represent a specific constituency and hold regular constituency office hours where residents can raise concerns; MLAs can raise local issues through Assembly debates, written or oral questions to ministers, and Private Members' Bills; MLAs sit on Assembly committees, scrutinising government departments and spending on behalf of constituents; MLAs vote in the Assembly, giving constituents a direct voice in decisions on laws and budgets that affect them.
评分标准
Level 1 (1-2 marks): Identifies one or two ways with little explanation. Level 2 (3-4 marks): Explains a range of ways with some development. Level 3 (5-6 marks): Explains a range of ways in detail (e.g. constituency work, committee scrutiny, voting) with clear reasoning. Any other valid point credited.
题目 3 · Short Structured Explanation
6 分
Explain some of the tactics that pressure groups use to achieve their aims, and explain why the tactics used may vary between groups.
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
Indicative content: tactics include lobbying MLAs/MPs directly, organising petitions, holding peaceful demonstrations, running media/publicity campaigns, and (for insider groups) formal consultation with government departments. Reasons tactics vary: insider groups with close government links may rely on quiet lobbying, while outsider groups without such access may need high-profile demonstrations to be heard; the nature of the cause and the size of the membership base also shape which tactics are practical and effective.
评分标准
Level 1 (1-2 marks): Identifies one or two tactics with little explanation. Level 2 (3-4 marks): Explains a range of tactics with some reasoning for why they vary. Level 3 (5-6 marks): Explains a range of tactics in detail and clearly explains why tactics vary (e.g. insider/outsider status, nature of cause, membership base). Any other valid point credited.
题目 4 · Extended Source-Prompted Explanation
8 分
Source B 'A public inquiry into press conduct recommended a stronger, independent regulator with the power to fine newspapers and order corrections. Newspaper editors argued that this would threaten the free press's ability to investigate and hold politicians and other powerful people to account.'
Using Source B and your own knowledge, explain some of the rights and responsibilities that the media has in a democratic society.
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
Indicative content: from Source B - the media has a right to freedom of the press so it can investigate and criticise powerful people without unreasonable state interference; this must be balanced against a responsibility to report accurately and to respect the findings of inquiries into press conduct (such as the Leveson Inquiry). From own knowledge - responsibilities include accurate and fair reporting, informing and influencing public opinion responsibly, holding power to account through investigative journalism, and respecting people's privacy and dignity; rights include publishing without pre-censorship and protecting journalistic sources. A full answer explains the tension between the right to a free press and the responsibility to report responsibly.
评分标准
Level 1 (1-3 marks): Basic, undeveloped explanation with limited/no use of the source. Level 2 (4-6 marks): Sound explanation of rights and/or responsibilities, drawing on the source OR own knowledge. Level 3 (7-8 marks): Detailed, well-developed explanation of both rights AND responsibilities, drawing on both Source B and own knowledge (e.g. reference to the Leveson Inquiry / arguments for and against greater regulation). An answer that fails to refer to the Source can be awarded a maximum of Level 2 (6 marks).
Unit 1: 部分 C
Answer all extended essay questions assessing political arguments and evaluation.
2 题目 · 26 分
题目 1 · Single-Sided Argument Essay
10 分
"Northern Ireland should lower the voting age to 16."
Make a case in support of this statement.
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
Indicative content in support: 16-year-olds can already work, pay taxes and join the armed forces, so it is inconsistent to deny them a vote on decisions (e.g. taxation, education policy) that affect them directly; political education delivered in schools means many 16-year-olds are well informed about current affairs; involving young people in voting earlier, while many still live at home and are engaged in education, is more likely to establish a lifelong habit of voting, addressing the problem of chronically low youth turnout; Scotland and Wales have already lowered the voting age to 16 for some elections, providing a working precedent and evidence base; giving 16-year-olds a vote could increase youth engagement with, and interest in, political issues such as education and the environment that directly affect their futures. A strong answer selects and develops several of these points with specific examples and sustains focus on the proposition throughout.
评分标准
Level 1 (1-3 marks): Limited, generalised points in support, little development or focus on the proposition. Level 2 (4-6 marks): Some relevant points in support with limited development/examples; reasonable focus on the proposition. Level 3 (7-10 marks): A range of well-developed, relevant points in support with specific examples (e.g. existing responsibilities at 16, the Scotland/Wales precedent, building lifelong voting habits), sustained focus on the proposition throughout.
题目 2 · Balanced Evaluation Essay
16 分
Evaluate the following statement: "The Single Transferable Vote is a fairer electoral system than First Past the Post."
In your answer you should include: • arguments in support of the statement; and • arguments against the statement.
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
Indicative content in support: STV is a form of proportional representation, so the share of seats a party wins more closely reflects its share of votes, unlike FPTP where a party can win a majority of seats on a minority of the vote; STV allows voters to rank candidates in order of preference, so votes for less popular candidates are not simply 'wasted' but transfer to the voter's next choice; STV tends to produce more diverse representation and can better reflect a divided society such as Northern Ireland, encouraging power-sharing rather than one-party dominance. Indicative content against: STV is more complex for voters to understand and for officials to count, which can delay declaring results; STV in multi-member constituencies can weaken the direct constituency link, since several MLAs share responsibility for one area rather than a single clearly-accountable MP; proportional systems like STV often produce coalition or power-sharing government, which some argue can be less decisive or stable than the strong single-party governments FPTP tends to produce; FPTP is simple, quick to count and produces a clear, easily identifiable winner. A judgement should weigh fairness/proportionality against simplicity/clear accountability and reach a substantiated conclusion.
评分标准
Level 1 (1-4 marks): Limited, one-sided or generalised points; weak QWC. Level 2 (5-8 marks): Some relevant points on both sides with limited development; adequate QWC. Level 3 (9-12 marks): Well-developed points on both sides with examples; good use of political terminology; clear QWC. Level 4 (13-16 marks): A wide range of well-developed, balanced points on both sides, precise terminology, and a substantiated overall judgement; excellent QWC. Answers which fail to address both sides of the argument will be unable to access the mark range beyond Level 2 (8 marks).
Unit 2: 甲部
Answer all questions. Complete factual recall, definitions, and matching tables.
14 题目 · 24 分
题目 1 · Single-mark Recall
1 分
Name one factor that has increased interdependence between countries.
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
Countries are increasingly interdependent because of factors such as globalisation, growing international trade, technological developments, cross-border terrorism, and shared environmental issues.
评分标准
[1] Any one valid factor.
题目 2 · Single-mark Recall
1 分
Name one aim of the European Union.
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
The EU's founding aims include political union, a single market, and freedom of movement of people, goods, services and capital.
评分标准
[1] Any one of: political union; single market; freedom of movement.
题目 3 · Single-mark Recall
1 分
In what year did the UK hold its referendum on membership of the European Union?
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
The UK referendum on EU membership was held on 23 June 2016.
评分标准
[1] 2016.
题目 4 · Single-mark Recall
1 分
Name one permanent member of the United Nations Security Council.
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
The five permanent members of the UN Security Council, each holding a veto, are the UK, the USA, France, Russia and China.
评分标准
[1] Any one of: UK; USA; France; Russia; China.
题目 5 · Single-mark Recall
1 分
What does the acronym 'NATO' stand for?
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
NATO stands for the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, a military alliance founded on collective defence.
评分标准
[1] North Atlantic Treaty Organization. Accept minor wording variation.
题目 6 · Single-mark Recall
1 分
Name one category of migrant.
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
Migrants are commonly grouped into refugees, asylum seekers, internally displaced people, and economic migrants.
评分标准
[1] Any one of: refugee; asylum seeker; internally displaced person; economic migrant.
题目 7 · Single-mark Recall
1 分
Name the UN agency responsible for protecting refugees.
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
The UNHCR (UN Refugee Agency) is the principal international organisation responsible for protecting refugees and helping to resolve refugee problems worldwide.
评分标准
[1] UNHCR / UN Refugee Agency.
题目 8 · Two-mark Recall / Definition
2 分
Give two arguments against UK membership of the European Union.
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
Arguments against membership commonly cited include a loss of full national control over immigration and borders, the financial cost of EU membership contributions, and the requirement to follow EU rules and regulations set outside the UK.
评分标准
[1] for each valid argument identified, up to [2]: e.g. loss of border/immigration control; financial contributions; following EU rules made outside the UK; loss of some sovereignty. Any other valid point.
题目 9 · Two-mark Recall / Definition
2 分
What is meant by the term 'freedom of movement' within the European Union?
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
Freedom of movement is one of the EU's founding principles: it allows citizens of member states to travel to, live in, work in and study in any other member state without the need for a visa or separate work permit.
评分标准
[1] Basic idea of citizens being able to travel/live/work across member states; [1] development, e.g. reference to no visa/work permit needed. Any other valid point [2].
题目 10 · Two-mark Recall / Definition
2 分
What is meant by the term 'sanctions' as a tool used by the UN Security Council?
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
Sanctions are economic or trade penalties, such as restrictions on trade, travel bans, or freezing of assets, imposed by the Security Council on a state or organisation to pressure it into changing its behaviour without resorting to military force.
评分标准
[1] Basic idea of economic/trade restriction imposed on a state; [1] development, e.g. purpose is to pressure a change in behaviour without military force. Any other valid point [2].
题目 11 · Two-mark Recall / Definition
2 分
Give one factor that causes conflict between countries and briefly explain it.
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
One factor causing conflict is a desire for independence, where a group or region within a state seeks to break away and govern itself, which can lead to violent conflict if the central government resists. Other valid factors include cultural, moral or religious differences, economic and trade disputes, and the desire for security.
评分标准
[1] Identification of a valid factor (e.g. desire for independence; cultural/religious differences; economic factors; desire for security); [1] brief explanation of how it causes conflict.
题目 12 · Two-mark Recall / Definition
2 分
What is meant by the term 'internally displaced person'?
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
An internally displaced person (IDP) is someone forced to leave their home because of conflict, persecution or disaster, but who has not crossed an international border, remaining within their own country - unlike a refugee, who has crossed into another country.
评分标准
[1] Basic idea of being forced to flee one's home; [1] development, e.g. remains within own country's borders, distinguishing from a refugee. Any other valid point [2].
题目 13 · Two-mark Recall / Definition
2 分
Give two economic or social benefits of migration to the host country.
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
Migration can benefit the host country through additional tax revenue from migrant workers, filling skills and labour shortages, and increased cultural diversity.
评分标准
[1] for each valid benefit identified, up to [2]: e.g. tax revenue; filling skills gaps/labour shortages; cultural diversity. Any other valid point.
题目 14 · Matching Grid
5 分
Match the correct term from the list below to its description in the grid. Write the correct term next to each number.
1. A person who has fled their own country and formally applied to another country for protection, but whose claim has not yet been decided. 2. A person who has moved to another country mainly in search of work or a better standard of living. 3. The UN agency responsible for protecting and assisting refugees worldwide. 4. A person who has fled their home because of persecution, conflict or violence and has been granted protection in another country. 5. A person who has been forced to flee their home but remains within their own country's borders.
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
1 = Asylum seeker (claim not yet decided); 2 = Economic migrant (moves for work/living standards); 3 = UNHCR (the UN Refugee Agency); 4 = Refugee (persecution/conflict, granted protection abroad); 5 = Internally displaced person (flees but stays within own country).
评分标准
[1] mark for each correct match: 1-Asylum seeker [1]; 2-Economic migrant [1]; 3-UNHCR [1]; 4-Refugee [1]; 5-Internally displaced person [1]. Maximum [5].
Unit 2: 乙部
Answer all questions using the provided source material and your own knowledge.
4 题目 · 25 分
题目 1 · Source-Prompted Description
5 分
Source A 'Since leaving the EU, UK exporters to the bloc have faced new customs paperwork and border checks that were not required when the UK was a member. Meanwhile, the UK government has signed new trade agreements with countries outside Europe that it was previously unable to negotiate independently.'
Using Source A and your own knowledge, describe some of the effects of the UK's departure from the European Union.
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
Indicative content: from Source A - new customs paperwork and border checks have added cost and delay for UK exporters trading with the EU; the UK has been able to negotiate its own independent trade deals with non-EU countries, which it could not do as an EU member. From own knowledge - UK citizens lost automatic freedom of movement to live and work in EU states; the UK no longer contributes to or benefits from EU funding programmes; the UK regained full control over areas of law and regulation previously set at EU level.
评分标准
Level 1 (1-2 marks): Basic, undeveloped description with limited/no use of the source. Level 2 (3-4 marks): Sound description drawing on the source OR own knowledge. Level 3 (5 marks): Detailed, well-developed description drawing on both Source A and own knowledge. An answer that fails to refer to the Source can be awarded a maximum of Level 2 (4 marks).
题目 2 · Short Structured Explanation
6 分
Explain some of the causes of migration, including both push and pull factors.
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
Indicative content: push factors (negative conditions that drive people to leave) include war and armed conflict, poverty, and human rights abuses; pull factors (positive conditions that attract people to a destination) include better job opportunities, higher wages, safety, and the presence of family or an existing community from the same country. A strong answer explains both categories with examples and shows how push and pull factors often combine to shape a person's decision to migrate.
评分标准
Level 1 (1-2 marks): Identifies one or two causes with little explanation. Level 2 (3-4 marks): Explains a range of push and/or pull factors with some development. Level 3 (5-6 marks): Explains a range of both push and pull factors in detail, ideally with examples. Any other valid point credited.
题目 3 · Short Structured Explanation
6 分
Explain some of the ways in which the United Nations Security Council attempts to establish and maintain peace and security.
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
Indicative content: mediation - encouraging negotiation between conflicting parties to reach a peaceful settlement; sanctions - imposing economic or trade restrictions to pressure a state or group to change behaviour; peacekeeping missions - deploying UN troops/observers to monitor ceasefires and protect civilians; use of force - authorising military action, as a last resort, under the UN Charter when other measures have failed. A strong answer explains more than one method, ideally with an example.
评分标准
Level 1 (1-2 marks): Identifies one or two methods with little explanation. Level 2 (3-4 marks): Explains a range of methods with some development. Level 3 (5-6 marks): Explains a range of methods (e.g. mediation, sanctions, peacekeeping, use of force) in detail, ideally with a relevant example. Any other valid point credited.
题目 4 · Extended Structured Explanation
8 分
Explain some of the arguments for and against the UK re-joining the European Union.
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
Indicative content for re-joining: easier, tariff-free trade with the large EU single market, removing the customs paperwork and border checks introduced since leaving; restoring freedom of movement, allowing UK citizens to live, work, study and retire across EU member states; a greater collective voice in international affairs and access to EU funding programmes and collaborative schemes (e.g. in research or education). Indicative content against re-joining: the UK would again have to make significant financial contributions to the EU budget; it would need to accept EU rules and regulations, including free movement of people, over which the UK government would have limited direct control; the process and terms of re-joining could be lengthy, complex and may not replicate the UK's previous membership terms (e.g. rebates or opt-outs).
评分标准
Level 1 (1-3 marks): Basic, limited explanation with little detail. Level 2 (4-6 marks): Sound explanation of arguments for OR against, with some accurate detail. Level 3 (7-8 marks): Detailed, accurate explanation of arguments both for AND against re-joining, with specific and relevant points on each side.
Unit 2: 部分 C
Answer all extended essay questions evaluating international politics and rights protection.
2 题目 · 26 分
题目 1 · Single-Sided Argument Essay
10 分
"The Good Friday Agreement has been the most effective agreement in securing lasting peace in Northern Ireland."
Make a case in support of this statement.
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
Indicative content in support: the Agreement established power-sharing/consociationalism, giving both unionist and nationalist communities a stake in government rather than one-party dominance; it secured decommissioning of paramilitary weapons, removing armed groups' capacity for large-scale violence; the early prisoner release scheme helped bring former paramilitaries into the political process rather than continued conflict; it created new human rights and equality safeguards, including the Equality Commission for Northern Ireland and the Northern Ireland Human Rights Commission; the dramatic and sustained fall in politically-motivated deaths since 1998, compared with the preceding Troubles, is strong evidence of its core success; subsequent agreements (the St Andrews Agreement, the Hillsborough Castle Agreement, the Stormont House Agreement) show it created a durable framework that could be renewed and adapted rather than collapsing. A strong answer selects and develops several of these points with specific examples and sustains focus on the proposition.
评分标准
Level 1 (1-3 marks): Limited, generalised points in support, little development or focus on the proposition. Level 2 (4-6 marks): Some relevant points in support with limited development/examples; reasonable focus on the proposition. Level 3 (7-10 marks): A range of well-developed, relevant points in support with specific examples (e.g. power-sharing, decommissioning, fall in violence, follow-up agreements), sustained focus on the proposition throughout.
题目 2 · Balanced Evaluation Essay
16 分
Evaluate the following statement: "The legacy of the past remains the greatest ongoing challenge to peace in Northern Ireland."
In your answer you should include: • arguments in support of the statement; and • arguments against the statement.
查看答案详解收起答案详解
解题
Indicative content in support: unresolved issues from the Troubles - including how to investigate unsolved killings, provide truth and information to victims' families, and deal fairly with allegations against both paramilitaries and the state - remain deeply contested and repeatedly stall political agreement; disagreement over 'dealing with the past' has contributed to periods of Assembly collapse and continued mistrust between communities; commemorations and disputes over how the conflict is remembered continue to generate community tension. Indicative content against: other divisive issues, such as disputes over flags, emblems and the route of contentious parades, cause frequent and highly visible community tension and are arguably just as significant a challenge; ongoing socio-economic divisions, including continued residential and educational segregation between communities, arguably present a deeper structural challenge than unresolved legacy cases specifically; institutional/political instability (repeated Assembly suspensions over issues such as the Northern Ireland Protocol/Windsor Framework) shows that current-day political disagreements, not only legacy issues, threaten the peace process. A judgement should weigh the centrality of legacy issues against these other ongoing challenges and reach a substantiated conclusion.
评分标准
Level 1 (1-4 marks): Limited, one-sided or generalised points; weak QWC. Level 2 (5-8 marks): Some relevant points on both sides with limited development; adequate QWC. Level 3 (9-12 marks): Well-developed points on both sides with examples; good use of political terminology; clear QWC. Level 4 (13-16 marks): A wide range of well-developed, balanced points on both sides, precise terminology, and a substantiated overall judgement; excellent QWC. Answers which fail to address both sides of the argument will be unable to access the mark range beyond Level 2 (8 marks).
想知道自己有几分把握?
thinka 是 DSE 学生在用的 AI 练习应用,提供无限量练习题、即时自动批改和详细解题步骤。超过 100,000 名学生用它确认自己是真的会,而不只是「以为会」。